Dr Showkat Hussain shah
Hospitals are sanctuaries not because of their architecture or technology, but because of the relentless presence of those who serve within them. These are the places where human suffering gathers, and yet it is in these very halls that resilience quietly endures. Their sanctity is not ordained by ritual, but is renewed, every day, by the courage of doctors, nurses, and medical staff who choose to return, moment after moment, shift after weary shift.
When Presence Is Targeted
The recent assault on a resident doctor at the Government Medical College, Jammu, pierced more than the skin — it struck at the trust that binds caregivers to the society they serve. In a moment of immense personal grief, a relative lashed out — not at medical incompetence, but at the cruel limits of what medicine can offer.
This act of violence was not isolated; it echoed across wards and clinics far beyond that hospital. It fractured something essential — a shared understanding that those in white coats are not enemies but allies in anguish in times of crisis. When simply being present becomes dangerous, the foundational ethos of medicine is shaken. The profession has never promised miracles, only presence — yet even that is now under threat.
The Changing Reality for Caregivers
• Eroding Trust:
Once revered, the white coat no longer guarantees respect. Increasingly, it feels like insufficient armor against public outrage and misplaced blame.
• Growing Hesitation:
Words are now softened, and routes through hospitals are quietly altered — not just for greater empathy but as measured steps toward safety.
• Emotional Toll:
Where there was once pride, there is now fear. Enthusiasm has turned to exhaustion. Many healthcare workers, young and old, ask: Is this still worth it?
Why Presence Matters
Medicine is not the dominion of certainty or miracle—it is the art of showing up. The deepest trust in this profession has grown not from perfect results, but from an unwavering willingness to witness, comfort, and stay.
When fear replaces assurance and presence must be calculated for safety, something more than skill is lost. What makes medicine meaningful—the “tender, gritty willingness” to sit with the unknown—is endangered. Without presence, medicine becomes technical; it is presence that makes it human.
Pathways Forward
1. Stronger Legal Protection
• Make violence against healthcare workers a cognizable, non-bailable offense across India.
• Ensure comprehensive enforcement of existing laws, turning paper promises into absolute protection.
2. Safe and Sacred Workspaces
• Recognize hospitals as sensitive public spaces, protected like airports or courts.
• Install real-time surveillance, raise the standard of on-site security, and develop clear response protocols for violent incidents.
3. Revitalize Medical Communication
• Train healthcare professionals in empathetic, clear communication, not just clinical skills.
• Establish routine family updates, creating openness that can defuse fear and anger.
4. Balanced Media Portrayal
• Urge responsible journalism that neither deifies nor demonizes healthcare workers.
• Promote nuanced storytelling that honestly portrays modern medicine’s power and limits.
5. Reform Medical Education
• Prepare medical students for the profession’s emotional burdens and real-world challenges.
• Training in de-escalation, grief counseling, and emotional resilience should be included alongside clinical excellence.
6. A Societal Shift in Perspective
• Separate presence from responsibility for outcomes.
• Recognize that grief and uncertainty are not excuses for violence—and blame, misplaced in pain, only deepens the rupture.
A Flickering Flame, Not Yet Extinguished
What happened in Jammu was not just an assault on a caregiver—it wounded a belief that sincerity, kindness, and presence were enough to ensure the safety of those who serve. Yet even in the rubble of trust, a small flame still flickers and that fragile flame can light the corridors again — if we protect it.
Protecting the presence of medical workers isn’t just about defending individuals. It’s about preserving something essential to our humanity: guaranteeing that someone will be there in despair, someone will stay, and someone will care.
If we lose this, we will mourn a profession in crisis and a society that turned its back on the very hands that sought to heal it.
Follow our WhatsApp channel
