The devastating cloudburst at Chashoti village in Paddar has left an indelible scar on Jammu and Kashmir, with at least 61 lives lost, over 80 missing, and hundreds injured. The sheer magnitude of the tragedy-flattening a makeshift market, a langar site, homes, temples, and vehicles-is a grim reminder of nature’s fury compounded by human negligence. Despite repeated early warnings of heavy rainfall and cloudburst risks by the JKUTDMA, little was done on the ground to anticipate or prevent such a catastrophe. Authorities had already curtailed the Shri Amarnath Yatra owing to inclement weather. Yet, the Machail Mata Yatra-drawing thousands of pilgrims annually-remained unregulated and unchecked. There was no registration mechanism, no headcount of pilgrims, and no real-time monitoring. With three consecutive holidays ahead, an extraordinary rush of devotees was expected. Chashoti-the last motorable point and a congregation hub-was overflowing with pilgrims starting or ending their arduous journey. It was, tragically, a perfect recipe for disaster.
The main langar, where hundreds of pilgrims were resting, was located directly in the line of a vulnerable nallah. Shockingly, no authority deemed it necessary to anticipate the risks of sudden flash floods or debris flow. Adding to the vulnerability, hotels, houses, and even a makeshift taxi stand had sprung up in the same exposed area, turning the natural downslope of the mountain into a death trap. When the cloudburst struck, its ferocity was unmatched-massive boulders and torrents of water descended with such force that no one had a chance to escape, let alone run for safety. The crater left at the site, nearly 35 feet deep and 500 feet wide, stands as a chilling testimony to the unimaginable impact.
The rescue and relief operations have been nothing short of Herculean. Over 400 personnel from the Army, NDRF, SDRF, CRPF, Police, and BRO, supported by local volunteers, are battling against time, rain, and terrain. Heavy machinery, explosives for boulders, and dog squads are all being pressed into service. However, the magnitude of the disaster has outstripped even the most diligent efforts. With bodies buried under metres of debris and boulders, retrieval will take time. The absence of proper road connectivity has further hampered timely evacuation and relief. Still, glimpses of hope emerged when one langar operator was found alive after 30 hours under the rubble-proof that the combined efforts of rescue forces are saving lives against impossible odds.
The medical fraternity, too, has risen to the challenge. Government Medical College Jammu has once again become the lifeline, handling dozens of critical referrals. In one night alone, 66 patients were admitted, and 25 emergency surgeries were conducted-an extraordinary feat that underscores the dedication of doctors and paramedics working under crushing pressure.
But as we mourn the dead and pray for the missing, the larger questions cannot be brushed aside. This disaster was not merely the wrath of nature-it was an avoidable calamity. Lessons from Kedarnath in 2013, the Amarnath cave tragedy in 2022, and even recent Darhali have clearly not been internalised. Cloudbursts are natural phenomena that cannot be prevented, but the vulnerability of human settlements and unregulated pilgrim infrastructure in the line of such hazards is entirely man-made. Direct downslope of mountain nullahs, which act as natural conduits for cloudburst-triggered floods, is bound to bulldoze anything coming its way, as Chashoti’s ruins painfully illustrate. Regular vulnerability mapping, strict enforcement of disaster preparedness protocols, and regulated pilgrim management must become the new normal. It is better to heed weather warnings, and the yatra can be put on hold. The responsibility for any such lapse rests with every official in the chain of command.
No compensation, however generous, can substitute for the lives lost or heal the grief of families that have lost multiple members. But the best tribute to those who perished will be to ensure that such negligence is never repeated. The tragedy at Chashoti is a painful reminder that nature may strike without warning, but human foresight and preparedness can save countless lives.
Follow our WhatsApp channel
