Excelsior Correspondent
SRINAGAR, July 10: Amar Singh Club, Srinagar, under its ‘Common Interest Conversations’ program, hosted a thought-provoking seminar on “Healing With Honor – Ethics & Empathy in Medical Practices.” The session was chaired by renowned neurologist Dr Sushil Razdan and presided over by Senior Advocate Zaffar A Shah.
Nasir Hamid Khan, Secretary of the Club, outlined the objectives of the ‘Common Interest Conversations’ initiative, which has previously addressed issues like digital addiction, drug abuse and eldercare.
Speaking on the topic, Khan stressed that while the Hippocratic Oath is widely recognized, India’s ancient texts like the Charaka Samhita laid down ethical foundations for medicine over 3,000 years ago. He highlighted rising concerns over medical malpractices, including unjustified stent use and increasing Caesarean-section rates driven by economic incentives.
Khan also cited a Supreme Court case-Apex Laboratories vs CIT-where the court upheld a CBDT circular denying tax deductions on incentives given to doctors, underscoring the need for ethical marketing in pharma. He also raised concerns about the influence of pharma companies on prescriptions, contrasting India’s voluntary UCPMP code with the US Sunshine Act.
Zaffar A Shah emphasized the need for accountability in medical practice and questioned the lack of punitive action against negligent doctors. He pointed to referral commissions and economic motivations behind certain procedures as areas of concern.
Dr Sushil Razdan reflected on the rising costs of healthcare and overburdened doctors, particularly in Government hospitals. Dr. Abdul Wahid highlighted the emotional toll on doctors and the importance of empathy from both sides. Dr Mustaq Margoob recalled legendary Kashmiri doctors like Dr Ali Jan for their personal connection with patients. Dr Naveed Nazir noted the growing trust deficit in healthcare.
Participant Peerzada Ashiq suggested regular audits of prescriptions to ensure accountability without targeting individual doctors. The session concluded with an engaging Q&A and closing remarks by Zaffar A Shah.
Follow our WhatsApp channel
