CAG finds major corporate governance lapses in PSEs
Irfan Tramboo SRINAGAR, Oct 5: Majority of the public sector enterprises in Jammu and Kashmir failed to hold minimum required board meetings during 2022-23 as the Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) found major corporate governance lapses in the PSEs. With...
Irfan Tramboo
SRINAGAR, Oct 5: Majority of the public sector enterprises in Jammu and Kashmir failed to hold minimum required board meetings during 2022-23 as the Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) found major corporate governance lapses in the PSEs.
With nearly three-fourths of the 33 active enterprises reviewed by the CAG failing to hold the minimum number of Board meetings in 2022-23 and an equal proportion failing to conduct their mandatory Annual General Meetings (AGMs).
Follow the Daily Excelsior channel on WhatsApp
Only nine of the 33 enterprises held the required four Board meetings during the year, while 24 fell short of the statutory requirement. In 10 enterprises, no Board meeting was held at all.
The findings are part of the CAG's Composite Audit Report for the period ended March 2023 and are contained in its assessment of corporate governance in Government-owned companies in J&K.
Under Section 173(1) of the Companies Act, 2013, every company is required to hold at least four Board meetings in a year, with not more than 120 days between two consecutive meetings.
However, the audit found that the shortfall among the 24 defaulting enterprises ranged from 50 per cent to 100 per cent.
Among the enterprises that held no Board meetings during 2022-23 were the J&K Women's Development Corporation, J&K Small Scale Industries Development Corporation, J&K State Industrial Development Corporation, J&K Industries, J&K Overseas Employment Corporation, AIC-J&K EDI Foundation, J&K Minerals, J&K Cable Car Corporation, and the Jammu and Srinagar Mass Rapid Transit corporations.
J&K Power Transmission Company Limited and J&K Agro Industries Development Corporation Limited held only two Board meetings each, while several enterprises, including the J&K SC/ST/Backward Classes Development Corporation, J&K Handicrafts (Sales and Export) Development Corporation and J&K Handloom Development Corporation, held just one.
The Jammu and Srinagar Smart City companies held two and one Board meetings, respectively.
The audit found an equally serious lapse in the conduct of AGMs.
As many as 24 of the 33 enterprises did not hold their mandatory annual meetings during 2022-23, despite Section 96 of the Companies Act requiring every company to conduct an AGM each year.
Among those that failed to hold AGMs were Kashmir Power Distribution Corporation, J&K Power Transmission Corporation, J&K State Power Trading Company, J&K SC/ST/Backward Classes Development Corporation, J&K State Industrial Development Corporation, J&K Industries, J&K Overseas Employment Corporation and J&K Medical Supplies Corporation.
The list also included AIC-J&K EDI Foundation, J&K IT Infrastructure Development, J&K Forest Development Corporation, J&K Cable Car Corporation, J&K Tourism Development Corporation, J&K Projects Construction Corporation, Jammu Smart City, Srinagar Smart City, the Jammu and Srinagar Mass Rapid Transit corporations and J&K Power Development Corporation.
Other enterprises that did not conduct AGMs included the J&K Women's Development Corporation, J&K Handicrafts (Sales and Export) Development Corporation, J&K Handloom Development Corporation, J&K Infrastructure Development Finance Corporation and J&K Police Housing Corporation.
The deficiencies extended beyond Board meetings and AGMs to other key corporate governance requirements.
The CAG found that 10 UTPSEs were required to have the prescribed number of independent directors, but only J&K Bank Limited had appointed the required number during 2022-23.
Similarly, 10 enterprises were required to constitute Audit Committees and Nomination and Remuneration Committees, but only J&K Bank had constituted both committees during the year.
The audit also found significant gaps in the appointment of Company Secretaries.
Of the eight eligible enterprises, only two had appointed whole-time Company Secretaries, one had a part-time Company Secretary and five had none.
The CAG has recommended that the Government direct the concerned administrative departments to ensure compliance with the Companies Act, 2013, while the Boards of Directors of the enterprises should ensure adherence to the applicable statutory provisions.
The review covered 33 active Government companies for 2022-23. Six inactive companies and J&K Cement Limited, which was non-operational, were excluded from the assessment.

