Delhi
police demand extra money to
give info under RTI
NEW DELHI, Mar 26: The Right to
Information Act might be hailed as
peoples power in democracy, but
data under it may not come for free for
an NGO that wanted information on missing
children.
Nav
Shristi-an NGO working for women
and child rights-was shocked when two
police stations in the capital demanded
Rs 12,274 each for disclosing information
on missing and kidnapped children in
Delhi under the RTI.
"We
were prompted to file an FIR after coming
across complaints from poor people that
police was not taking their cases
seriously," director of the NGO
Reena Banerjee said.
But it
were the monetary charges listed by the
police that rattled the social worker
more.
According
to the reply to the RTI application,
"one Sub-Inspector at Rs 773 per day
for one day, one head constable at Rs 451
per day for one day and 13 constables
from police stations at Rs 425 per day
for two days would be needed for the
information to be gathered."
This
amounted to a total of Rs 12,274 as
mentioned in the letter from these two
police stations.
The west
Delhi and south-west Delhi police
stations had given a break-up of the
amount they wanted in order to deliver
the services.
In all, 12
police stations were approached and these
were the only two that cited any charges
to be paid for the information.
Unhappy
over the issue, Banerjee approached the
Central Information Commission (CIC) in
this regard.
"Why
cant they give us the complete
information. And if ten of the 12 police
posts could part with the information
free of cost, then why not these
two," Banerjee questioned.
As per the
RTI rules, the applicant has to pay Rs
two per page to get the information.
According
to a CIC official, "the concerned
officer can charge rates only as
prescribed by the State Government. It
should be a reasonable amount."
However,
he was clueless on the definition of
"reasonable amount".
When
contacted, south-west district DCP
Shalini Singh said, "We know we have
asked for a certain sum of money to do
the job. What we have done is rightful
under the laws of RTI."
RTI
activist Arvind Kejriwal said, "the
RTI Act does not prescribe any such
charges. The Sub-Inspector and the
constable will work on a holiday or on a
working day to retrieve such information
and he is a paid servant.
"It
is their job. They cannot ask for extra
charges being government servants,"
he said. (PTI)
Rahul
asks youth to press for internal
democracy in parties
MYSORE, Mar 26: "At 37, I am
an old person in India. Majority of India
is younger than me," said Congress
General Secretary Rahul Gandhi asking the
youth to plunge into politics and prevail
upon political parties to usher in
internal democracy.
Noting
that 70 per cent of Indias
population is young, Gandhi, on a
campaign trail ahead of the assembly
elections in Karnataka, said while old
(people) are to be respected for their
experience, there is value and strength
in youth as well. "In a sense, youth
is the future".
Lamenting
that political parties lacked internal
democracy, the Nehru-Gandhi family scion
asked the youth to raise their voice to
highlight the issue.
"Youth
should ask the question: When there is
democracy in poll booth, why does it not
exist in political parties", Gandhi,
who is on a four-day tour of Karnataka,
asked at a function at Nanjangud, near
here, last evening.
"No
body is asking this "fundamental
question... Why is it that in a
democratic country where everybody has
vote, the same spirit is missing in
political parties," he said.
He urged
the youth to enter politics and make it
different and bring refreshing change by
"resisting the same game that every
politician plays".
Interacting
with tribal students at Vivekananda
Smaraka Hospital, part of Swami
Vivekananda youth movement, at Sirgur
near here, he criticised opponents of the
Rs 60,000 crore loan waiver package
announced in the Union Budget.
He said
the critics are silent on the
non-performing assets (with banks) of big
industrialists.
Gandhi,
however, said there cant be
"unlimited loan waiver" noting
that financial limitation does not allow
for such a move. "Policy-making is
all about balance, it has to be
forward-looking, and not
disruptive".
When a
tribal girl asked him about his dream for
new India, Gandhi said: "My dream
for India is every child should
dream".
"I
intend to become an expert on tribal
culture," he said in response to
another query.
Gandhi
said the difference between the rich and
poor in the country is having an
opportunity. People should be provided
access to opportunity, he added.
President
of the hospital, R Balasubramaniam, said
he was impressed by Gandhi who "is
clear on the direction that India should
take and is aware on the inquities
existing in India and rich-poor divide.
"He
(Gandhi) spoke a lot about education.
Education opportunities should be equal.
One should not sterotype children as
rural, urban and tribal. Opportunities
for everybody should be the same,"
he said. (PTI)
Sexual
harrassment charge against
Speaker; house adjourned
BHUBANESWAR, Mar 26: An allegation of
sexual harassment levelled against Orissa
Assembly Speaker Maheshwar Mohanty by a
woman marshal led to the adjournment of
the House twice after he sought an
impartial inquiry into the charge.
As soon as
the House assembled this morning, the
speaker made a suo motu statement
referring to media reports about charges
of sexual harassment of a woman marshal
of the assembly levelled against him and
proposed setting up of a House Committee
to probe the matter.
Terming
the allegation as false and baseless, he
said it was the fallout of actions
initiated against indisciplined employees
and also part of a "conspiracy in
which important persons were
involved".
Stating
that it would be improper on his part to
preside over the proceedings till the
truth is inravelled, Mohanty left the
chair which was subsequently occupied by
Deputy Speaker Prahallad Dora.
While
terming the Speakers action as a
"dignified move, Congress
leader Narasingha Mishra said an inquiry
into the matter was a must but probe by a
House Committee would be meaningless.
Though
Parliamentary Affairs Minister Raghunath
Mohanty supported the Speakers
suggestion for a probe, Mishra and
NCPs Arun Dey suggested adjournment
of the House for holding discussion on
the issue in the Speakers chamber
to decide the nature of any probe.
After
Government Chief Whip Kishore Mohanty
supported their proposal, the House was
initially adjourned for 30 minutes and
later till 1 PM.
Terming
the allegation made against the Speaker
as very serious, Narasingha Mishra said
"When such charges are levelled, the
entire House stands condemned. I suggest
that the House be adjourned for holding
discussion on the matter in his
chamber."
"I
have no objection if the Speaker allows
discussion on it in the house," but
it would be proper to discuss the matter
inside the chamber, he said adding that
probe by a House Committee would be only
to buy time.
Observing
that the dignity of the house was in
question following the allegation, Arun
Dey said the Chief Minister should make a
statement on the issue.
"It
was a terrible shock for me when I heard
the Speaker saying that big people are
involved" in a conspiracy to defame
him, he said. (PTI)
|