NC
stalls entire business, FMs budget reply;
seek resignations of Qarra, Afzal
A day full of uproar in
Assembly
*NPP, BJP, JSM MLAs troop into Well, call for
Governors rule, fresh polls
By Sanjeev Pargal
JAMMU,
Jan 23: Opposition National Conference
today stalled proceedings in Legislative Assembly
almost for entire day leading to two adjournments
and blocked reply of Finance Minister Tariq Hamid
Qarra on budget debate demanding resignations of
Mr Qarra and Forest Minister Qazi Mohd Afzal for
their indictment in Kundal Committee report.
In an unusual
practice, nearly 20 NC MLAs also took out a
procession within the Civil Secretariat premises
after the House was adjourned both the times
shouting massive slogans against coalition
Government especially Mr Qarra and Mr Afzal.
The issue was
virtually deadlocked with NC insisting on
dismissal of both the Ministers and declaring
that it would not allow proceedings of the House
to run till the tainted Ministers
resign or are removed from the Ministry while
Deputy Chief Minister Muzaffar Hussain Baig ruled
out resignations saying there was no indictment
of the Ministers in Kundal Committee report.
Speaker Tara Chand and Mr Baig offered the
Opposition a full fledged debate on the report
after Question Hour tomorrow, a proposal shot
down by the Opposition saying the report was
"self speaking" and had pointed out
"knee deep involvement" of Ministers in
the "irregularities" and they must go.
While National
Panthers Party (NPP) didnt join the
protests, its Legislature Party leader, Harshdev
Singh along with Jammu State Morcha (JSM) MLA
Ashwani Sharma trooped into well of the House and
staged a sit-in before staging a walk-out
demanding dissolution of Assembly, dismissal of
Government, imposition of Governors rule
and holding fresh elections in the State. BJP MLA
Jugal Kishore also called for dismissal of
Government and Governors rule in the State
alleging both the Government and the Assembly
have failed to carry out any business. He too
walked out of the House. Later, three other NPP
MLAsBalwant Singh Mankotia, Yashpal Kundal
and Faqir Nath also staged a walk-out making a
similar demand.
Day long
pandemonium in the Assembly marred by massive
slogans by Opposition and counter slogans by
PDP-Congress members, joined by the coalition
Ministers, reached its climax when the House met
at 4.07 pm after lunch break. As NC again
rejected the Deputy CMs proposal for a
debate on Kundal report tomorrow and insisted on
Ministers resignation, the Speaker asked
Finance Minister Tariq Hamid Qarra to start his
reply on budget debate.
As soon as Mr
Qarra stood up for reply, all NC members, who in
the morning session had been shouting slogans
from their benches, trooped into well of the
House shouting "Gali Gali Mein Shor Hai,
Qazi Qarra Chor Hain", "Corrupt
Ministron Ko Nanga Karo", "Jangal
Choron Ko Nanga Karo", "Choron Ko Fansi
Do", "Ganderbal Mein Shor Hai, Yeh
Sarkaar Chor Hai", "Batmaloo Mein Shor
Hai, Yeh Sarkaar Chor Hai" etc. (Batmaloo
and Ganderbal are represented by Mr Qarra and Mr
Afzal respectively). Almost all PDP and Congress
MLAs including some Ministers countered the
sloganeering shouting "Kundal Report Pe
Behas Karo".
The NC MLAs tore
the papers in their hands and threw them in the
House. Papers flung all over the Well of the
House.
As NC MLAs
moved towards podium of the Speaker, they were
surrounded by watch and ward staff of the
Assembly. Mr Qarra tried to go ahead with his
reply but nothing was audible in the din. Barely
two minutes into the Finance Ministers
reply, it was a virtual ruckus in the House with
slogans of "Jungle Chor Hai Hai"
renting the entire House. Finding no other
option, the Speaker adjourned the House till
tomorrow.
After adjournment
of the House, there was not let up in
anti-Government sloganeering by NC MLAs for about
five minutes. The Opposition members came out of
the House and marched in a procession in Civil
Secretariat premises shouting "Chor Sarkaar
Hai Hai", "Corrupt Sarkaar Hai
Hai", "Beimaan Sarkaar Hai Hai",
"Mulazimon Mein Shor Hai, Secretariat Mein
Shor Hai, Hinduon Mein Shor Hai, Musalmanon Mein
Shor Hai, Sikhon Mein Shor Hai, Masjidon Mein
Shor Hai, Mandiron Main Shor Hai, Gurudwaron Mein
Shor Hai, Yeh Sarkaar Chor Hai". They walked
upto the Secretariats entrance and held a
massive demonstration for a couple of minutes
before dispersing.
As House resumed
its sitting after lunch break, the Deputy Chief
Minister (in the absence of Chief Minister Ghulam
Nabi Azad, who is in New Delhi), said the
Government was ready for a debate on Kundal
Committee report.
NC MLA
Sharief-ud-Din Shariq countered the demand saying
the report was "self speaking" and
there was no scope left for a debate. The
Ministers must go, he said.
Another NC member
Dr Mehboob Beg added that the two Ministers could
"influence investigations" ordered by
the Government through Vigilance Organisation and
Crime Branch into irregularities pointed out by
Kundal Committee.
"Shariq
Sahib Aapko Khoon Peene Ki Aadat Ho Gayi Hai.
Aapko Bahut Zayada Payaas Lagi Hai. (Shariq
Sahib, you have become blood thirsty)", Mr
Baig remarked referring to the earlier
resignation of School Education Minister Peerzada
Mohd Sayeed. Mr Baig again requested the NC MLAs
that the Chief Minister will also return tomorrow
and will listen to debate on the report.
"We
didnt ask for an inquiry. The Chief
Minister had himself set up the Committee to go
into mess in Forest Department. When the
Committee has given a self speaking report, these
Ministers must go", senior NC leader Ajay
Sadhotra remarked.
Charging the
National Conference with shying away from debate,
Mr Baig asked the Opposition members to tell him
the pages of Kundal report where the two
Ministers have been indicted. Dr Mehboob Beg
replied that Chief Minister was on record saying
the Ministers were not "directly
involved" which means they were
"indirectly involved" in the scams.
Earlier in the
morning, as soon as the House assembled and the
Speaker called for Question Hour, all NC MLAs
moved to front row. Leader of Opposition Abdul
Rahim Rather said he and all his party MLAs have
gone through Kundal Committee report yesterday
and found "knee deep involvement" of
present Forest Minister (Qazi Afzal) and his
predecessor (Tariq Hamid Qarra).
"Prima facie
involvement of both of them has been established
by Kundal Committee report and they both should
be sacked immediately. Vigilance Organisation and
Crime Branch cant probe the cases referred
to them till both Ministers occupy their chair as
they can "influence the probe" and
"tamper with the record", Mr Rather
said.
"Its
scandal worth crores", Mr Sadhotra remarked.
"Yeh Mantri Jail Jane Ke Layak Hain, Yahaan
Rahne Ke Laayak Naheen (these Ministers deserve
jail, not a seat here)", Mr Shariq shouted.
PHE Minister and
PDP leader Dilawar Mir was quick to get up from
his seat and charged the NC members with enacting
a drama. "Mr Rather has himself charged some
members of the House with wasting time. Now what
he is doing"? he asked.
"Aap Doodh
Kay Dhoole Naheen Hain. Aapke Bhi Scandals Hum
Samne Layenge (You are not clean. We will expose
your scandals also)", Mr Mir shouted.
"Chor Log Hain Aap. Sare Chor Hain (You are
thieves. You all are thieves)", the Minister
went on.
It was virtually
for the first time when all PDP-Congress
Ministers besides the MLAs stood up from their
seats and countered NC. "Gundagardi Naheen
Chalegi. Dramewazi Naheen Chalegi (Hooliganism
and drama wont do)", Congress MLA
Girdhari Lal shouted loudly as he trooped into
well. He was followed by PDP members Sartaj
Madni, Shanti Devi and Ghulam Hassan Khan
(suspended from the party), all of whom strongly
countered the NC slogans. NCs slogan of
"Choron Ko Saza Do" was countered by
PDP with "Chor Machaye Shor". NC MLAs
replied with "Daaku Machaye Shor".
In a rare case,
all Ministers sitting on front and second row of
treasury benches also stood up from their seats
to counter NC protests. In the melee, Qazi Afzal
was also heard passing some remarks against the
Opposition which were not audible in the din.
Amidst a free for
all situation, the Speaker adjourned the House
within 5 minutes of Question Hour. Even after
five minutes of adjournment, NC members continued
slogans in the House including "Kundal Bhi
Kahta Hai, Ro Ro Ke Kahta Hai, Cheekh Cheekh Kay
Kahta Hai, Har Page Pay Kahta Hai, Yeh Sarkaar
Chor Hai".
The House resumed
after more than one and half hour adjournment.
The Speaker told NC members that Government
functionaries have spoken to the Chief Minister
in New Delhi and the Government has agreed for a
discussion on Kundal report after Question Hour
tomorrow. However, the NC MLAs refuse to budge
from their stand and started shouting slogans
which were again replied by PDP and Congress
legislators.
However, the
treasury benches stopped slogans and the Chair
went ahead with debate on budget. Jehangir Mir,
Dr Manohar Lal Sharma, Sartaj Madni, Raman
Mattoo, Moulvi Abdul Rashid and Kanta Choudhary
took part in the debate amidst slogans from the
Opposition members.
"They (the NC
people) couldnt open schools but we have
given Universities and Colleges to the people.
They only showed dreams to people but we made
them realise by launching Muzaffarabad bus and
other such measures. We have opened 10,000 new
primary schools. They gave us Task Force, POTA,
Ikhwanis and Papa Kishtwari but we have given
people a terror free atmosphere", Mr Madni
said as NC MLAs continued to shout "10 Arab
Ka Hisaab Do", "Coalition Sarkar Sharam
Karo, Dariya Mein Dhoob Maro".
All of a
sudden, the House was rocked by a fresh protest,
this time by NPP Legislature Party leader
Harshdev Singh and JSM MLA Ashwani Sharma, who
entered the House and straightway proceeded to
well of the Assembly.
"Dissolve
the Assembly. There is no seriousness either on
part of the Government or the Opposition. Both
have made a mockery of the House. Impose
Governors rule in the State and hold fresh
elections", Harshdev said, adding
"there is no name of law and Constitution,
both within and outside the House".
"Assembly Ko
Bhang Karo, Governor Rule Impose Karo", Mr
Singh shouted as both MLAs sat on a dharna in
Well of the House.
"A deliberate
attempt is being made to silence the voice of
Jammu", Harshdev and Ashwani Sharma shouted
as they staged a walk-out from the House after
about 10 minutes dharna.
As BJP MLA Jugal
Kishore started his speech on the budget, he too
mounted a frontal attack on both coalition
Government and treasury benches saying one side
was asking for autonomy and other for self rule.
Mr Qarra was suggesting his own currency.
"From where the Government will bring crores
of rupees to pay salary to the employees if the
State is given autonomy or self rule"? he
asked.
Charging the
Government with having failed to run the House
and curb corruption, he called upon the Governor
to dismiss the Government and hold fresh
elections. "Militants are being killed in
the houses of ruling party leaders. Neither this
Government nor this Assembly is working",
the BJP MLA shouted, trooped into Well of the
House, marched upto Speakers podium and
started shouting but his voice too was not
audible as NC members continued their slogans.
The BJP MLA then staged a walk-out in the House.
Now it was the
turn of three NPP MLAs, Balwant Singh Mankotia,
Yashpal Kundal and Faqir Nath who marched upto
front row saying the Government has no right to
stay in power and Governor rule must be imposed
in the State. All three later staged a walk-out
in the House.
During brief
debate on the budget in post-adjournment session,
the NC members kept sitting on front row and
indulged in massive sloganeering.
Talking to
reporters outside the Assembly, Deputy Chief
Minister Muzaffar Hussain Baig, flanked by Mr
Qarra, Mr Afzal and other Ministers including Taj
Mohi-ud-Din, Dilawar Mir, Abdul Aziz Zargar and
Pir Mohd Hussain besides PDP MLAs, Abdul Rehman
Veeri and Mohd Khalil Bandh, pointed out that
Kundal Committee has submitted its report within
12 days and has given certain recommendations on
"tentative conclusions".
"This
tentative view of Kundal report is subject to
verification. No where, the Committee has given a
final verdict except for saying may be this is an
irregularity etc", Mr Baig noted.
Asserting that
there was no allegation against Minister in the
report, he invited the NC for a full fledged
debate in the House on the report tomorrow and
declared that even if prima facie it was proved
that any of the two Ministers had taken graft,
they will resign.
"They have
come to the House decided that they are not going
for a debate in the House as they will be exposed
since there was no irregularity mentioned in the
report", the Deputy Chief Minister said.
Saying that the
Chief Minister could have even rejected tentative
recommendations of Kundal Committee, Mr Baig said
the CM even then decided to refer the cases to
Vigilance Organisation and Crime Branch for
investigations.
Regarding import
of timber, he pointed out that it was the Finance
Minister himself who had stopped the entire
exercise after it was pointed out that one of the
officer was connected to the firm from which
timber was proposed to be imported.
On allotment of
work on Amani basis, Mr Baig said this was done
as tenders were boycotted by Jammu contractors
for extraction of timber seeking 100 per cent
hike in rates. Even NC has also resorted to Amani
basis, he pointed out.
To a question, Taj
Mohi-ud-Din said it was the NCs game plan
to adjourn the House since die but we will insist
on a debate on Kundal report in the House.
Talking to
reporters, Leader of Opposition Abdul Rahim
Rather observed that Kundal report has
"unambiguously" pointed out that not
only senior officers of Finance Department but
two Ministers of coalition Government had
"knee deep involvement" in corruption.
"Im
saying this with a sense of responsibility that
Kundal has pointed out irregularities in Forest
Department with concerned Ministers
approval", he said and asked:
"doesnt this mean that they are party
to bunglings"?
He added that even
if the Ministers role wouldnt have
been mentioned they couldnt have escaped
their responsibility as a senior most officer,
the Chief Secretary, has repeatedly said that
decisions were taken with the Ministers
approval.
"What more
the Chief Minister wants? Who will believe the
CMs slogan of corruption free
administration and transparency if he didnt
make the Ministers to resign"? Mr Rather
asked and said: "if the Ministers
didnt resign it will put a question mark on
credibility of the Chief Minister and will render
his slogans on anti-corruption hollow".
He insisted that a
decision to import timber was taken to
"benefit a particular firm. As this was for
the first time that the Government was adopting a
policy on import of timber, the Government should
have taken the Legislature into confidence, he
said.
The NC leader said
the Kundal Committee has pointed out that the
same officer was made SFC MD who was pushing the
agenda of timber import. Contracts were given to
unregistered contractors and families of
blacklisted contractors. GMs and DMs were
transferred within 6 months. Clearly, these
allegations formed the basis for a prima facie
cases against the Ministers, he added.
Noting that 20
scams mentioned by Kundal panel have been
recommended to Vigilance and Crime Branch, the
Leader of Opposition wanted to know that whether
it is possible that the two agencies can hold an
independent probe when the "accused"
continue to occupy the Ministers chairs.
Referring to the
Excelsior report that 999 fire incidents took
place in two years, he said timber was being
burnt for vested interests.
He said Qazi Afzal
has himself admitted that the Forest Department
has been ruined. "An accused who is
confessing his crime has to be punished", he
observed.
On Kundal
Committee also pointing fingers on a Forest
Minister in NC Government, Mr Rather said
"we will not tolerate him. We will take
appropriate action".
|