EDITORIAL

Out of the box

We in this State are quite used to listening to the expression "out of the box". Busybodies mention it day in and day out. We shall not bother about them this Sunday. Let's spend this morning thinking about more pleasant out-of-the-box solutions. Before we proceed let's clarify that we have been propelled in this direction by a message received through e-mail: "Imagine this. You are driving along your car on a wild, stormy night, it's raining heavily, when suddenly you pass by a bus stop, and you see three people waiting for a bus: 1. An old lady who looks as if she is about to die; 2. An old friend who once saved your life; and, 3. The perfect partner you have been dreaming about. Which one would you choose to offer a ride to, knowing very well that there could only be one passenger in your car? Think before you continue reading (This is a moral/ethical dilemma that was once actually used as part of a job application). You could pick up the old lady, because she is going to die, and thus you should save her first; or, you could take the old friend because he once saved your life, and this would be the perfect way hence to pay him back. However, you may never be able to find your perfect mate again. The candidate who was hired (out of 2000 applicants) had no trouble coming up with his answer. He simply answered: 'I would give the car keys to my old friend and let him take the lady to the hospital. I would stay behind and wait for the bus with the partner of my dreams.' Sometimes, we gain more if we are able to give up our stubborn thought limitations. Never . ..more

Officers crunch in Army

By Lt. Col. Surendra Sharma

The British Indian Army had the tradition of service coming down from one generation to another. This practice continued till 1960s. Thereafter, there . ..more

State reorganisation commission

By Kalyani Shankar

When Congress leader Veerappa Moily made a statement on the creation of a second State Reorganisation Commission (SRC) in Hyderabad last week, . ...more.

Rising oil prices

By Sreedhar

With crude oil prices crossing $ 100 per barrel in the beginning of 2008, quiet changes are taking place in the global order. Suddenly the major crude oil producing countries like those among the Persian Gulf countries and Venezuela in South America have ..more

J&K producing 600 doctors every year
TALES OF TRAVESTY

By Dr. Jitendra Singh

In the last decade or so, the number of MBBS graduates that India produces every year has multiplied by several thousands and the number is going up each day. A small State like Jammu and .......more

EDITORIAL

Out of the box

We in this State are quite used to listening to the expression "out of the box". Busybodies mention it day in and day out. We shall not bother about them this Sunday. Let's spend this morning thinking about more pleasant out-of-the-box solutions. Before we proceed let's clarify that we have been propelled in this direction by a message received through e-mail: "Imagine this. You are driving along your car on a wild, stormy night, it's raining heavily, when suddenly you pass by a bus stop, and you see three people waiting for a bus: 1. An old lady who looks as if she is about to die; 2. An old friend who once saved your life; and, 3. The perfect partner you have been dreaming about. Which one would you choose to offer a ride to, knowing very well that there could only be one passenger in your car? Think before you continue reading (This is a moral/ethical dilemma that was once actually used as part of a job application). You could pick up the old lady, because she is going to die, and thus you should save her first; or, you could take the old friend because he once saved your life, and this would be the perfect way hence to pay him back. However, you may never be able to find your perfect mate again. The candidate who was hired (out of 2000 applicants) had no trouble coming up with his answer. He simply answered: 'I would give the car keys to my old friend and let him take the lady to the hospital. I would stay behind and wait for the bus with the partner of my dreams.' Sometimes, we gain more if we are able to give up our stubborn thought limitations. Never forget to think outside of the box." Does this not remind us of an old popular puzzle? Once upon a time there was a boatman. He had a tough exercise to perform on one occasion. He was required to take a lion, a goat and some grass from one bank of a river to the other. Given the small size of his vessel he could carry only one of them at a time. He could escort lion first only at the risk of losing fodder to goat. Likewise grass could have been taken by him by making goat a sitting target of lion. He hit upon a remedy. He carried goat first and left it on the other side. He returned and ferried hay this time. He put fodder down and brought goat back along with him. This time he made sure that goat was left behind: he carried lion and left it with grass. He returned again, picked up goat and joyfully carried it to the other bank where lion was already with grass. Thus he was able to save all of his precious assets. Had he not thought of an out-of-the-box solution?

Obviously the boatman had never been to this city. Had he paid a visit we would have swamped him with our history and forced him to carry grass first leaving the two animals in each other's company? How could we allow him to insult the memory of Jambulochan? After all, the founder of Jammu was inspired by the sight of a lion and goat together drinking water from Tawi. Why can't we witness such heartening scenes of mutual existence these days? We as humans don't see eye to eye. What is worse is that we don't seem to like either if the other living beings think out of the box.

 

Officers crunch in Army

By Lt. Col. Surendra Sharma

The British Indian Army had the tradition of service coming down from one generation to another. This practice continued till 1960s. Thereafter, there was change in attitude and the generational practice was broken. There were more job opportunities in waiting for the younger generation. With the liberalization of economy in the 1990s Army became the last choice of a career. Children only from middle class preferred joining defence forces.

This is amply illustrated in both the entry-level institutions of the Army-the NDA at Khadakwasla and the IMA at Dehradun-there was a sharp decline in youngsters queuing up to join this year. The NDA, for instance, has a course vacancy of 300 but only 190 of the selected cadets joined this year. Things are even worse at IMA, with only 86 "gentlemen cadets" joining for a course vacancy of 250.

"It's a fact. We are not getting the right material…the corporate world pays much more than what the government and the armed forces can give. Young men find emoluments much better outside. It has become a big source of worry since we do not wish to lower our quality standards," admitted the chief of Army, General Deepak Kapoor.

The Indian Army, incidentally, is the largest voluntary force in the world, second only to the Chinese People's Liberation Army in sheer numbers. There are enough volunteers at the level of jawans. The problem is the officer cadre. With its tough life, coupled with frequent transfers and poor promotional avenues, not many youngsters are willing to come forward due to the existing paltry salaries.

Unless and until service conditions are improved-and this goes far beyond just paying more money-young people will simply not want to join the Army as officers. It takes 16-18 years to become a colonel in the Army, which is equivalent to a deputy secretary, something that an IAS officer becomes in eight years. An IPS officer becomes SP in 4-5 years, but it takes an Army officer 13-year to reach the comparable rank of Lt. Colonel.

General Deepak Kapoor was probably indulging in nothing more than loud thinking when he mentioned compulsory military training as a possible way to get over the problem of an officer shortage the Army is facing. Such proposals have been made also in the past, and as such do not need to be taken seriously.

For one, India's ethos militates against something as drastic as conscription. Even if the government ever manages to start discussing this proposal, it will never ever pass the political barrier. There is no way that Indian politicians and bureaucrats, who don't marry their daughters to Army officers, will ever allow their precious sons to go to a boot camp, much less on the firing line.

More importantly, conscription is generally a mean to fill the forces with foot-soldiers. But in India, there is no shortage of people lining up to join the Army as soldiers. In fact, there have been instances of stampedes when the Army has announced a recruitment drive. Even in the troubled Kashmir valley, young men have been lining up to enlist.

As far as officer shortage is concerned, the Indian establishment is in denial and is simply not willing to do what it takes to solve the problem.

There was a time when, despite such blatant inequities, people were crazy enough or desperate enough to join the Army. Not any more. With jobs aplenty in the private sector, who in his right mind will want to join the forces? Instead of conscription, the answer to officer shortfall lies in improving the salary, status and service conditions of Army officers.

Notwithstanding the fact that the Indian armed forces are still held in high esteem in society at large, there can be little disagreement that the status of the "man in uniform" has been steadily degraded in the 60-years since Independence. Even so, in the context of the high levels of unemployment in the country there is no dearth of volunteers for recruitment in the rank and file. The material may not be the best, but volunteers are forthcoming, and are being moulded with training into effective military professionals.

A problem exists in the officer cadre primarily because the terms and conditions for short service commissions are unattractive. This can only be remedied by equipping officers appropriately for re-entry into civilian life after they complete the terms of engagement, and ensuring that the quality of life and the status they enjoy are worth making sacrifices for.

An oft-repeated refrain that youngsters seeking commissions in the Indian armed forces are not of the desired standard is patently untenable because young officers have never been found wanting. They have laid their lives on the line ever since Independence, in leading from the front; in Jammu and Kashmir in 1947-48, in the 1965 and 1971 wars, in the Kargil conflict, and on a daily basis in the ongoing counter-insurgency operations.

The profession of arms has always been seen as a noble one. The young people who volunteer for service as officers or in the ranks are not looking only for monetary benefits. They look for a certain quality of life and a status in society that make up for the relatively meagre emoluments.

The other motivation for our young officers and soldiers has always been the pride of the paltan or the regiment. If that pride is to be preserved and a sense of discipline induced in society, two measures are recommended. Firstly, "military service" for a period of three to five years in the armed forces be made mandatory for everyone seeking employment in central and state government service, including police, paramilitary forces, and in PSUs, etc. Secondly, joining the NCC is made mandatory for all students at senior school and university level.

If the Sixth Pay Commission gives more monetary incentives to defence service personnel it is likely that the younger generation would be once again attracted to join the defence forces. That will help in bridging the gap between the jawans and officers. INAV

 

State reorganisation commission

By Kalyani Shankar

When Congress leader Veerappa Moily made a statement on the creation of a second State Reorganisation Commission (SRC) in Hyderabad last week, the Congress strategists did not expect much reaction from elsewhere.

UP Chief Minister Mayawati, however, set the ball rolling. While celebrating her birthday on January 15, Mayawati demanded trifurcation of the state into Harit Pradesh, Poorvanchal and Bundelkhand, with the objective of upstaging the Congress. Mayawati's reaction gives an indication of what to expect from other States like Maharashtra, Karnataka and Gujarat where demands for smaller states are long pending.

Moily's statement came in the backdrop of the demand for a separate Telengana state for which a movement has been going on for more than 60 years. There are arguments for and against small states. Votaries of small states feel that they would have focussed development citing Haryana and Himachal Pradesh. There are others who think that this may open up a Pandora's box. They fear that the regional passions may be incited in states like Maharashtra, U.P, Karnataka and Gujarat. Also, they argue that not all small states are doing well and cite the example of Chhattisgarh, Jharkhand and Uttarakhand.

The SRC idea is not new as it crops up whenever the demand for small states comes up. The Congress seems to be clutching at every straw hoping to make electoral gains in the coming Lok Sabha and Assembly polls. After the humiliation in UP and the Gujarat defeat, the leadership is being persuaded to trifurcate U.P in the hope that such a step may improve Congress prospects. The party leadership has been told that a second SRC may pacify sentiments in states like Maharashtra, Gujarat and Karnataka.

The immediate provocation is the unrest in Andhra Pradesh where the Congress is in power since 2004 with the support of the Telengana Rashtra Samithi, which was born on the overwhelming regional sentiment in favour of a separate Telengana state. With 14 months left for the next elections, Moily's statement was meant to test the waters before announcing a second SRC. After seeing the violent reaction, he quickly withdrew.

The issue of creating smaller states has been a matter of debate within the Congress. While the Common Minimum Programme of the UPA had skirted a direct commitment, a sub-committee headed by Pranab Mukherjee was set up to look into the Telengana issue. Even after three and a half years, there is no consensus. So the Congress is now toying with the idea of a second SRC.

The Telengana demand has been surfacing on and off for 60 years. Before 1947, Telengana was part of the Hyderabad state of Nizam. After its integration with the Indian Union in 1948, it became part of Madras Presidency. When Andhra Pradesh came into being, it became part of the state but continued to remain backward. In 1969-70, there was a violent agitation for a separate Telengana in which at least 300 people lost their lives. Since then, the separate Telengana demand has been surfacing on and off with no strong leader to carry on the movement. Even Dr. Chenna Reddy, who led the agitation earlier, did not touch the issue later when he became the Chief Minister twice. Before the 2004 Assembly and Lok Sabha elections, K. Chandrashekhar Rao, an expelled Telugu Desam leader, successfully floated his Telengana Rashtra Samithi.

The new regional party joined hands with the Congress and won some seats in Lok Sabha as well as Assembly polls. Rao and his colleague, A. Narendra, became ministers in the UPA government. However, within two years, they left the Cabinet because their demand was not conceded. Now, with just 15 months to go for the next Assembly elections, the TRS is queering the pitch despite problems in the regional outfit.

When Moily made his remark, local Congress leaders led by G. Venkataswamy had no other option but to speak the TRS language. Their problem has been compounded because the Naxalites, who are running a parallel government in Andhra Pradesh, are fully supporting the separate Telengana demand.

There is also the political angle to the issue. The BJP, which is for small states, was coy about supporting the separate Telengana before 2004 when Telugu Desam was an outside supporter of the NDA but changed its stand after the TDP withdrew support to the NDA. Telugu Desam opposes the move. The local Congress is divided on the issue with Chief Minister Rajashekhara Reddy leading the dissention. The CPI-M is opposed to a separate state while the CPI has become soft.

At the central level, the Left parties are opposing smaller states. RJD Minister Raghuvansh Prasad Singh has said it will open the Pandora's box. The NCP is not keen. In such a situation, the Prime Minister has beat a retreat, saying there is no decision on setting up a second SRC even thought he Congress Working Committee had recommended it.

The UPA government should be careful before setting up a second SRC. No doubt, governance has become a big issue, and the big states are not able to meet the aspirations of the people. However, will creating small states resolve the issue or create more problems? Are the demands for small states justified? What is the progress in the recently-created small states like Jharkhand, Chhattisgarh and Uttarakhand? Will the political parties use this emotive issue to further their own interests? These are questions that need to be gone into carefully before setting up the second SRC. While there may be a case for Telengana, the real question is governance and not the size of the state. Telengana should be treated as a stand-alone issue and tackled. Now the Congress has to deal with not only the TRS but also its own local leaders. (IPA Service)

 

Rising oil prices

By Sreedhar

With crude oil prices crossing $ 100 per barrel in the beginning of 2008, quiet changes are taking place in the global order. Suddenly the major crude oil producing countries like those among the Persian Gulf countries and Venezuela in South America have started asserting themselves because of their financial clout with their newly acquired petrodollars, in the emerging global order. Many observers feel that sudden spurt in crude oil prices during the last two years is largely due to increased demand from the major economies of Asia, like India and China.

A quick look at the global crude oil prices during the past seventeen years, from 1990-1991 onwards it becomes clear that the prices of crude oil have gone up by more than 100 percent. If we compare it with 1971, the first year of crude oil price hike in the contemporary political history of the world, the price has increased by more than two thousand times. In the past crude oil prices increased because of political instability in the Persian Gulf Region like Yom-Kippur war of 1973, Islamic revolution in Iran in 1979, Iraqi invasion of Kuwait in 1990 and Operation Desert Storm in 1991. These are some of the examples which created certain amount of uncertainty in the supply of crude oil (though not in reality) by the major oil producing countries. According to many commentators the fear syndrome, a sort of physiological fest and not actual disruption of supplies, that resulted in sharp increased of crude oil prices.

In 2007, for instance oil had risen alongside gold after news of Benazir Bhutto's death, which unnerved financial markets. "Pakistan is a crucial country in the region and prospects of political uncertainty are leading to some nervousness (which is reflected in) gold, bond and oil prices rising and the dollar dipping," said Audrey Childe-Freeman, European economist at CIBC bank in London.

Bhutto's killing hit American stock markets, which were also depressed by weaker-than-expected US durable goods data. Oil had surged to one-month highs in the previous session following Turkey's raid on Kurdish guerrilla targets in northern Iraq.

"Turkish bombing of Kurdish guerrilla targets helped it on its way," said Kevin Blemkin, oil broker at MF Global. He said this had reminded the market of potential risks to crude supplies in the Middle East. Oil prices have risen 57% since the start of 2007 and touched a record high of $99.29 on November 21, boosted by concerns over shrinking supplies ahead of winter and weak dolar.

However, after the US invasion of Iraq in 2003 the prices of crude oil were gradually escalating but not in a geometrical proportion. The market disequilibrium in crude oil, demand outstripping supply, created quiet market turmoil. The main producers were not willing to make adjustments in their crude oil production to keep a check on prices. With the result in the past two years itself international spot market prices of crude oil have increased much more sharply than at any time in the past.

According to various estimates that are in circulation, by mid 2007 the Persian Gulf oil producers are almost sitting on a trillion petrodollar looking for investments at right places. If the trend continues in 2008 too, the Persian Gulf countries may gain upper hand in the capital flow across the globe. They may even attempt to gain control over some of the major transnational corporations. For instance, Abu Dhabi a small little island state managed to bailout Citigroup Inc from a major financial crisis by infusing $7.5 billion. Even before this deal, Bahrain, Kuwait, Oman, Saudi Arabia, Qatar and the United Arab Emirates, spent about $124.3 billion in the past three years in buying up foreign companies, real estate and other assets. Similarly most of the economic sanctions imposed on Sudan were brushed aside by the members of the European Community and major players from Asia because of new found oil reserves there and the resultant flow of petro dollars.

If this trend in petrodollars continues, global economy will experience a sea change in the next decade. The major oil producing countries specially those in the Persian Gulf will be the hub of economic activity like in the 1970s. At that time the developed countries were able to escalate the prices of manufactured goods and recycle petrodollars. The famous six times revision of an estimate of building a naval dockyard by US contractors in a span of twelve months is now part of the folklore among students of economics across the globe.

All this may not be possible any more in Persian Gulf now. There is a literate population in these countries who are well aware of market mechanisms. Like in the past they can not be fooled around any more on prices of manufactured goods. In addition, the radical Islamic groups have become the moral policemen of all the bureaucracy in the oil producing countries. This apart, now there are other players in the market like China and India who can offer stiff competition to consumer goods from the developed world. For instance Marks and Spencers in London may be a nice place for a holiday shopping but no one is thinking that it is the ultimate destination to acquire all consumer goods.

Now it became a public knowledge that some of the major Arab oil producing countries are financing terrorism and violence across the globe. The argument being advanced by these Arab financiers is that the radical Islamic groups are a response to the terrorism and violence created by Zionist lobby from 1948 onwards. "Terrorism has to be met by terrorism only" seems to be the logic behind the Arab world supporting radical Islamic groups. How far this is correct can be debated. But with their new found riches through the increased crude oil prices, they have taken the covert warfare to new levels.

In the process the entire war on terrorism started after the 9/11 seems to have lost its focus. The great powers are able to protect themselves from further terrorist attacks but were not able to crack down people responsible, the so called leadership, for the incident of 9/11. The evidence forth coming in the media indicate that the radical Islamic groups and their financiers have penetrated into almost all segments of the society across the globe. Many observers feel that this is one of the reasons for the limited success of the US led war on terrorism.

The present indications are that the major markets in the developed world are likely to go into a long recession affecting the consumer behavior and his purchasing power for a long time to come. This aspect of the global economy is not being realized by many observers. Unlike in 1973, now the Arab oil producing countries are not imposing any sanctions of crude oil supplies on any country. This time they are quietly increasing the price of crude oil to abnormal levels which is bound to have serious repercussions on the developed world. The world as such has no immediate answers to this quiet oil war launched by the Arab oil producing countries. After the 1971 Project Independence study it became clear to everyone that there is no effective substitute energy source material for crude oil in the foreseeable future. Therefore one has to live with crude oil as an important energy source material and all the countries started working out an energy source mix where crude oil will be kept to the bare minimum.-CNF

J&K producing 600 doctors every year
TALES OF TRAVESTY

By Dr. Jitendra Singh

In the last decade or so, the number of MBBS graduates that India produces every year has multiplied by several thousands and the number is going up each day. A small State like Jammu and Kashmir is itself producing around 600 MBBS pass-outs every year if one takes into account the strength in the State's four medical colleges in addition to those of the Jammu and Kashmir candidates who manage MBBS seats in colleges outside Jammu and Kashmir or sometimes also in colleges outside the country in Bangladesh, Russia etc. These figures, however, do not take into account the number of BDS dentists or alternative medicine like Ayurveda/Unani doctors that the State produces every year.

Where do all these over half a thousand MBBS boys and girls from Jammu and Kashmir go every year ? Do all of them or most of them succeed in securing a decent professional vocation for themselves ? Are most of them employed, underemployed or unemployed? With the erstwhile National Conference Government having reserved 50% MBBS seats in State's Medical Colleges for girls, where are the nearly 300 lady doctors who pass out each year ? How far does a degree of MBBS or MD per se in present day and time actually translate into a career boost for a male graduate or a matrimonial boost for a female graduate ? Are the dividends or returns for these young medical graduates proportionate to their enormous input in terms of both labour as well as monetary investment ? And, last but not the least, what is the best method these medicos or thier parents have planned to recover back 40 to 50 lakh rupees paid in case of a management quota seat ?

The consequences of unplanned education policy, which are already manifest in every other field of education, have now begun to show ramifications in the field of medical education as well. While this has emerged as a countrywide phenomenon, it is worrisome to note that in Jammu and Kashmir itself, there are at present atleast 3,000 doctors who are unemployed. And yet, many of the doctors' posts in periphery are lying vacant because as a result of administration's indifference, the young doctors are unable to adjust to inhospitalble living and working conditions for which they can be hardly blamed. At the same time, 50% reservation for women candidates in State's Medical Colelges has led to a quixotic crowding of female doctors with several households having a young daughter or a young daughter-in-law who is a ‘‘non-working’’ lady doctor.

Thoughtless reservation quotas first at the admission level and later at the recruitment level make it virtually impossible for many a meritorious candidate to become a doctor or to later secure Government job as a doctor. As a result, there is today a rapid mushrooming of young doctors who are doctors either through reserved quota or through donation. Another serious fall-out of this is that medicine which was once a profession of the best and the brightest is fast getting reduced to be a business of mediocres and no wonder, of late, with the arrival of new vocational avenues, more and more meritorious pass-outs from Class 12, particularly boys, have begun to opt for streams other than medicine.

With little possibility of Government jobs for young medicos, the entry of corporate hospitals and nursing homes in metros and sub-metros however offers an opportunity but not for all. On the other hand, to set up an independent private practice is not easy atleast in the initial years and therefore a young doctor who has spent lakhs to earn an MBBS and who is under social pressure to make quick fortune finds himself tempted to indulge in scandalous malpractices like sale-purchase of kidneys or unncessarily prescribed exorbitant investigations or surgeries without indication like unwarranted caesareans or needlessly prolonged indoor admisisons in private nursing homes.

In a confusing scenario like this, the bare minimum remedy is to (i) plan a medical education policy taking into consideration the number of doctors actually required for each region (ii) base the admissions to MBBS both in Government and private medical colleges purely on merit and abolish reservation quotas as well as private management quotas (iii) and above all, to launch awareness drive for parent counselling and student counselling at pre-medical level so that those who make a bid for a career in medicine should do so not simply for the sake of it but must first understand why they are doing so.

But the question is, will all the vested social, political and bureaucratic interests ever allow any remedy to happen ? And if not, then the question-mark is wide open. The common man has no answer. Umapathy has no redemption in sight, a La, ‘‘Manzil Bhi Nahin, Manzil Ki Justjoo Bhi Nahin......’’



|
home | state | national | business | editorial | advertisement | sports |
|
international | weather | mailbag | suggestions | search |
subscribe | send mail |