Anti-Israel
"rabbis" face fallout from
Jewish world.
JERUSALEM, Dec 25: Jewish leaders from
across the globe have decried the sight
of six Jews with beards and black hats
embracing Iran's president at a
conference questioning the Holocaust,
believing their gesture hurt the faith.
The Nazis'
mass murder of six million Jews remains
one of the most sensitive issues for
Jewish people. Israel was partly founded
as a haven for Holocaust survivors.
Jews
continue to be alarmed by Iranian
President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, who since
coming to power in 2005 has sparked
international condemnation by terming the
Holocaust ''a myth'' and calling for
Israel to be ''wiped off the map''.
Despite
this, a small cluster of Jews took part
in the December conference. They say they
went under the banner of Neturei Karta, a
fringe ultra-Orthodox movement estimated
by many commentators to number around
100, which does not recognise the state
of Israel, and seeks its demise.
They
believe Jews must remain stateless before
the coming of the Messiah, and view the
Zionist movement -- which established
Israel
-- as an
abomination before God for founding a
state prematurely.
Even
before the Tehran conference, the
movement had angered many Jews by
supporting former Palestinian President
Yasser Arafat and having ties with
Islamist group Hamas.
The six
Jewish visitors to the conference in Iran
regard themselves as part of the Haredi
community -- a very conservative branch
of the Jewish faith, whose name in Hebrew
means those ''fearful'' of sinning.
''PROPAGANDA
TOOL''
But even
in Jerusalem's ultra-Orthodox Mea Sharim
neighbourhood, home to many detractors of
the Jewish state -- including some who
share Neturei Karta's anti-Zionist
beliefs -- many residents said those who
attended the Tehran conference went a
step too far.
''While we
do not agree with the secular state of
Israel, these people have desecrated the
name of God,'' said Haim Freid, an
ultra-Orthodox Jew who lives in Mea
Sharim. ''They do not represent us.''
A
spokeswoman for Yad Vashem, Israel's
Holocaust remembrance body, said the
group was ''an unfortunate caricature
that has been used as a propaganda tool
by the Iranian regime''.
Israel's
Ashkenazi Chief Rabbi Yona Metzger called
on rabbis worldwide to ban the Jewish
participants -- who were from the United
States and Europe -- from synagogues.
Agudath
Israel of America, which represents tens
of thousands of ultra-Orthodox Jews in
the US, said despite their Haredi garb,
the six were a ''disgrace'' and
''dangerous'' to Jews.
The
two-day Iranian government-sponsored
conference was also attended by
Westerners who have cast doubt on the
Holocaust, even though some of the
countries they come from have made it a
crime to deny that it happened.
At the
conference, Neturei Karta Rabbi Aharon
Cohen said Germany had carried out ''a
catastrophic policy and action of
genocide'' on the Jews, but said it was
open to question how many millions had
perished.
Neturei
Karta's leader in Israel, self-styled
Rabbi Yisrael Hirsch, said while it
''hurt when people deny the Holocaust
happened'' the Jews' participation in
Tehran was important.
''The
purpose was to reveal to the whole world
that the Iranians do not have any hatred
to Jews, they only oppose Zionism like we
do,'' he said, surrounded by volumes of
sacred Jewish scriptures at his modest
home in Mea Sharim.
''We
wanted to show that Zionism does not
represent the Jewish people.''
Hirsch, a
51-year-old U.S. Citizen by birth who
rejected Israeli citizenship, said he was
unable to go to Tehran because he lived
in Israel. Iran does not grant entry to
visitors with Israeli entry stamps in
their passports. Hirsch's father Moshe, a
New York-born rabbi, was Arafat's adviser
on Jewish affairs.
ANGER
Neturei
Karta, Aramaic for ''guardians of the
city'', was formed in Jerusalem in the
1930s as a bulwark against the growing
Zionist movement in what was then British
Mandate Palestine.
The large
and influential Satmar Hassidic sect,
which also opposes the state of Israel
and believes Zionism is an ''idolatrous
temptation'', is a traditional Neturei
Karta ally but has increasingly distanced
itself from the movement.
Satmar's
United States-based rabbinical leadership
described the Jews' attendance at the
Tehran conference as ''acts of madness''
and called on Satmar disciples and others
to shun those who ''give the go-ahead for
the spilling of Jewish blood''.
Many in
the ultra-Orthodox world believe Moshe
Hirsch, now taking a back seat in the
movement, steered Neturei Karta away from
its principles and represents a breakaway
sect by drawing it closer to militant
Muslim figures opposed to Israel, like
Hamas.
Israel
Eichler, a former Israeli lawmaker and
well-known Haredi commentator, described
their activities as ''anachronistic'' and
''anarchistic''.
''Even the
most anti-Zionist rabbis have declared
that in facing the outside world we need
to show a united front (with the state of
Israel),'' he told Reuters.
Yisrael
Hirsch is undeterred by those arguments.
''The
majority of the Haredi world opposes
Zionism in principle,'' he said. ''We are
sure one day Israel will cease to exist
just like the Soviet Union did.''
(AGENCIES)
Body of
Indian found in toilet.
DUBAI, Dec 25: The body of an
Indian real estate agent was found in
mysterious circumstances in the public
toilet of Dubai public transport station.
A cleaner
on Saturday found the body of S A P Habib
Rahman (45), in a standing position with
his back against the toilet wall, news
reports said.
Later, it
was presumed that Rahman, apparently,
died of a cardiac arrest while using the
toilet on Friday afternoon. (UNI)
When
faith and medicine collide
CHICAGO, Dec 25: Any nurse can walk
into a bad situation. The one Luanne
Linnard-Palmer can't forget came as she
readied a little boy for a blood
transfusion only to be told by his mother
''You know you're damning his soul to
hell!''
The
child's mother was a Jehovah's Witness, a
faith that rejects blood transfusions.
Her son had sickle cell anemia and had
become extremely weak.
''It blew
me away,'' Linnard-Palmer recalls years
later. ''I worried not only about my own
reaction but what was going to happen to
this child with a lifelong disease.''
The
incident planted the seeds for a newly
published book by the California nurse,
''When Parents Say No: Religious and
Cultural Influences on Pediatric
Healthcare Treatment,'' published by
Sigma Theta Tau International.
In the
case that was seminal to the book,
doctors went to court and got a four-hour
guardianship of the child so they could
carry out the transfusion against his
mother's will.
The boy
went home after the transfusion and the
nurse who had been so affected by the
case has no idea what happened to him
after that.
''American
families move, change jobs. There are no
longitudinal studies looking at this, at
what happens the next time they receive
medical care,'' she said in an interview.
The
challenges she recounts are both
religious and cultural.
A
14-year-old Muslim girl with severe burns
on her arm from a cooking oil spill was
recovering after surgery until her
parents heard the surgeon talk about a
graft made with pig skin. They demanded
it be removed and the girl was ultimately
left with almost no function in her lower
arm.
A preteen
girl with a large and rapidly growing
neck tumor was recommended for immediate
chemotherapy but her family said they
needed three to five days to pray with
their Christian congregation beforehand.
After officials threatened to take
guardianship of the child, she was
brought back for treatment after just one
day.
''But the
family had been willing to risk, not
maybe death, but the need for immediate
treatment in order to fulfill their
duties spiritually,'' Linnard-Palmer
said.
''Just
recently we had an Hispanic mother who
said through interpreters that in her
background men were the decision makers.
Her young son is a very brittle diabetic
cared for by an uncle who loads him up
with sugar after school,'' she said.
''So now
he's very ill. But she said she couldn't
go against the men in her house. If
they're going to give him sodas and
cookies they're going to do this,'' she
added.
LAYING-ON
OF HANDS
Linnard-Palmer,
a pediatric nurse at California Pacific
Medical Center in San Francisco and a
professor of nursing at Dominican
University of California in San Rafael,
believes that more time, training and
money are being spent these days on
helping medical personnel deal with
religious and cultural issues when it
comes to caring for children.
Large
urban hospitals, which tend to have more
resources, have been out in front. Her
hospital has an hour-long conference
every two weeks to discuss such problems,
she said, and when an incident occurs
there is intervention by psychologists
and chaplains as well as medical
personnel.
While the
Jehovah's Witnesses are often mentioned,
Linnard-Palmer says she has found
increasing complications involving
fundamental Christians.
''Over and
over I see people who say they won't
consent until they speak to a minister or
have a laying-on of hands,''she added,
causing delays in treatment but not
necessarily refusals.
Gaining
temporary guardianship through the courts
is a well-established precedent, she
said, though it does not happen all that
often. It can have different results --
with some parents relieved that the
matter has been taken out of their hands
despite their wishes but others who are
left in rage.
The extent
of the problem in the United States has
not been well documented. One
often-quoted study published in the
journal ''Pediatrics'' in 1998 found 141
deaths of children in the United States
over a 20-year period who were denied
medical treatment for religious reasons
but whose survival rate with treatment
would have exceeded 90 percent.
That study
estimated that there were many more
deaths which could not be documented.
Rita Swan,
one of the authors of that study, told
Reuters she believes the problem today is
not as bad as it was in the United States
20 years ago. But she said the problem is
still very difficult to measure since
some religious groups are not forthcoming
and deaths due to treatment delays are
not always recorded with that as the
cause.
''While we
don't hear of as many deaths in
faith-healing sects as we used to,
opposition to vaccines, for example, is
increasing and outbreaks of
vaccine-preventable disease are
increasing, some tied to religious
exemptions and some not,'' she added.
(AGENCIES)
|