EDITORIAL
Old warmth thawing
A friend in deed is the
friend we need. Nothing proves this better than the
Indo-Russian friendship spanning five eventful decades of
their history. All through the cold war when the world
was held in peace by the threat of sure destruction, the
two countries stood by each other. They fortified each
other against the onslaught of the world forces bent of
changing the world to their advantage by a brazen display
of narrow strategic interests. Even as India formulated,
fostered and ran the concept of
Non-alignment, she was a dependable ally of Russia, in
all its deeds and acts. And, so was Russia in her part of
the bargain. India then followed a singular hybrid of the
Marxism ....more
Osamas Kashmir
The reports say that Osama
bin Laden did pay a secret visit to Kashmir in the late
nineties. In cognito, of course. That was a Kashmir that
had been ravaged by his lieutenants and co-fliers in
terrorism. Yet that Kashmir must have been better than
any of the countries he had been to in his crusading
years. It was definitely better than Afghanistan he had
helped to devastate, with obscurantism over the years.
One does not know whether he liked it or not but he must
have been pretty uncomfortable......more
|
|
Pak-Taliban
Relations
By D R Ahuja
Pakistan Dictator Gen. Pervez Musharraf's sinister
efforts to gain control of Afghanistan in the
post-Taliban. ....more
Need
to boost
organic farming
By Radhakrishna Rao
The havoc unleashed by high tech farming based on the
widespread and indiscriminate use of agrochemicals has
once..more
RBI's
monetary and
credit policy
By K R Sudhaman
The Reserve Banks Credit Policy has had mixed
reactions. While the industry, hit hard by the economic
slowdown .... .more
Children's
literature in Hindi
By Damodar Agrawal
There is a lot of activity in the world of
childrens literature in Hindi. So much so that it
looks....... .more
Seeds
of new cold war
By K. V. S. Rama Sarma
A new cold war is taking birth in the strife-torn
Afghanistan. The American bombs that........ .more
|
EDITORIAL
Old warmth thawing
A friend in deed is the
friend we need. Nothing proves this better than the
Indo-Russian friendship spanning five eventful decades of
their history. All through the cold war when the world
was held in peace by the threat of sure destruction, the
two countries stood by each other. They fortified each
other against the onslaught of the world forces bent of
changing the world to their advantage by a brazen display
of narrow strategic interests. Even as India formulated,
fostered and ran the concept of
Non-alignment, she was a dependable ally of Russia, in
all its deeds and acts. And, so was Russia in her part of
the bargain. India then followed a singular hybrid of the
Marxism and capitalism. She was a democracy and thus a
natural ally to the democracies of the world. She was
socialistic in thought and deed and there stood close to
the leftist hearts. Ideologically she could ride either
boat and did that for years. Yet the world knew where she
would be found at the moment of reckoning, and counted
her in the Russian block for all practical purposes.
Together Russia, Soviet
Union as it was then, and India formed the other pole of
the world though USSR clearly was the senior partner
there. But India with its influence among the third-world
countries commanded a modicum of respect, all her own. A
factor there was the Indian penchant for trudging the
lone path. While being in the broad coalition
with USSR she did keep her own mind. However, the fact
that the democratic world was fiercely
amalgamated against the communists, and by default
against all that went with it ideologically or actually,
never gave India a chance to be critical of the block.
Even in Afghanistan the Americans laid up so closely with
Zia that India even if she wished could not be a party
there. So it happened with all the world, especially the
Indian part of the world where the American and British
strategies went right against the Indian interests.
Though few remember it now, Russia had not been the
original choice of friends for Nehru. He went
to America first, tried to speak his heart to them as
kinsmen in democracy, but the Americans turned so cold
that he lost heart in the very second speech in the US
Congress. The rest is the history of Indo-Russian
friendship.
Then. the Soviet Union
broke up. It broke up due to internal pressure, the
pressure caused by the high failure of the socialist
pattern of economy. Within years, the Indian economy,
suffered similar tremors. Fortunately she did not have
all our eggs in the basket of communism. And quickly put
in more capitalist baskets to save more eggs. With
capitalism, came markets and with open markets came the
natural friendship of kindred democracies
Nehru had hoped to cement on his first visit to USA! The
nineties were the happy honeymoon of Indo-US thaw that
finally saw Clinton-glow in Delhi. Then came the
war, Apparently it was a war after
Indias heart. But the way it is going along the old
American strategic route leaves little for the Indian
hopes. Now, as then, it has been impressed upon India
that she has to fight her wars herself, with her own
strategies and must have her friends on her side. That
was revealed to Russia during the Yeltsin years of
American courtship. Now the friends are back in the bear
hug, trying to comfort each other in this winter chill. A
good thaw it should prove, because it is a convergence of
national interests which any day are stronger than the
market ones.
Osamas Kashmir
The reports say that Osama
bin Laden did pay a secret visit to Kashmir in the late
nineties. In cognito, of course. That was a Kashmir that
had been ravaged by his lieutenants and co-fliers in
terrorism. Yet that Kashmir must have been better than
any of the countries he had been to in his crusading
years. It was definitely better than Afghanistan he had
helped to devastate, with obscurantism over the years.
One does not know whether he liked it or not but he must
have been pretty uncomfortable in a state that still had
a modicum of civilization in it. All has not been
destroyed yet, and that must rankle heavily with the
crusader who wants to see only prayer-halls and
hangmans nooses around. Was that why he though that
a renewed effort was needed to bring Kashmir under his
full spell ? The new rise in militancy there does
coincide with the reported time of his coming there. And
now, Kashmir certainly is going there with his terrorist
brethren spreading mayhem all around. Had he waited a
little more, before pontificating on the denial of
rights in Kashmiris he would have had more matter
to meat up his assertions.
But even now, his
predecessors and followers in terrorism have filled the
scene up with enough cruelties,
slaughters, killings and
violations to make him fill a tape and send
it out. And when al Jazeera videoed it out, few asked
whether cruelties, slaughters.
killings and violations were by
Indians or his lieutenants. Possibly not even the
Kashmiris asked that question, for they seem to have
singularly forgotten that Kashmir had seen no
cruelties, slaughters.
killings nor violations before the
jihadis infiltrated in and started the spree twelve years
ago. Then, the late Zia chided them on being
non-violent. With help of Osama and his cohorts
they have certainly violated Kashmir, its ethos and
mentor. But probably, they would not remember even that.
The peoples memories are said to be proverbially
short. And, hence they come to be ruled by the likes of
outright violators of rights, humans and civilization.
And so, none remembers to ask what does a Saudi, child of
American strategy, fed by the Pakistan, and sheltered by
far Afghanis have to do with Kashmir. Or have nothing to
do with his Arab brethren, right-less, rule-less,
freedom-less, in tight shackles?
|
Pak-Taliban
Relations
By D R
Ahuja
Pakistan
Dictator Gen. Pervez Musharraf's sinister
efforts to gain control of Afghanistan in
the post-Taliban scenario could not make
any headway. Rather Pakistan got a
stinging rebuff when the US Secretary of
State Colin Powell made it clear that
Islamabad will not be allowed to foist a
government of its choice in Afghanistan.
The next government in Afghanistan cannot
be dictated into by Pakistan, he
asserted. The alternative to Talibans
will have to be an international effort
under the auspices of the United Nations,
Powell told a congressional hearing.
There will be need to consult all of
Afghanistan's neighbours and countries
like India. China and Russia. Powell's
blunt remarks came in the wake of Gen.
Pervez Musharraf's insistence on a
dominant role for Pakistan in determining
Afghanistan's political future. To
perpetuate its hold on Kabul, Pakistan
has in recent days, tried its utmost to
marginalise the Northern Alliance that is
supported by Russia and India. In his
emphatic rejection of a grand role by
Pakistan in Afghanistan, analysts see
Powell tried to distance himself from the
criticism that the US was unwillingly
acquiescing in Musharraf's crafty plan to
co-opt ''modern Taliban elements in the
future set up''. Pakistan cannot be
allowed to do what it did before, namely
foisting a government of their choice''
he asserted. Pakistan also did an unwise
act by convening a meeting of Afgham
leader in Peshawar failing to attract
representation from the Northern Alliance
and offer rebel groups. Hence the need to
call another meeting in Turkey of Afghan
leaders of all Afghan groups.
In an
article M Ilyas Khan said Afghan
governmet have traditionally been hostile
to Islamabad. The Talibans are not the
first government to turn against
Islamabad. Kabul's border disputes with
Pakistan and the differences over the
nature and extent of Afghan transit trade
that has traditionally been routed
through Pakistan under treaties signed by
the British with Afghan governments have
always evinced an element of hostility
towards Pakistan. Over the past nine
years, however, Pakistan attempted to
install what it calls ''friendly''
regimes in Kabul. Ironically these two
turned hostile one after the other,
proving the long-standing position that
Kabul is a natural of India and not of
Islamabad.
Following
the demise of the communist regime in
1992, the Pakistan-based
Afghan-resistance groups agreed to share
power under an accord and an interim
government was installed in Kabul under
Sibghatullah Mujeddiedi. A moderate
Islamist in compliance with the accord
formula, Mujeddedi transferred power to
Burhanuddin Rabbani, another moderate,
two months later, though Rabbani was
given an extension in his term, he
refused to hand over power. He ruled
Afghanistan with the help of his Defence
Minister, Shah Masood, who had never
lived in Pakistan during the Afghan
Jehad. This fact was mentioned as the
reason why Masood's government ultimately
turned hostile to Pakistan.
Gulbuddin
Hekmatyar had no such reasons. Though
commanding the largest and most
influential Mujahideen's Party during the
resistance, he lived mostly in Pakistan
and was considered a ''surrogate'' of the
ISI. He fell out with President Rabbani
when the later refused to step down.
Though at a later stage he was appointed
Prime Minister in Rabbani's government,
he could not enter Kabul to assume office
due to fighting with Masood. He later
blamed the ISI for thus, saying the
President's plans did not include handing
over to a Pakhtoon Afghan. He now lives
in exile in Iran.
The
Taliban themselves have never been proud
of their ties with Pakistan. Instead
their second time leadership despises
Pakistan, when they call Punjabis. But
some extraordinary factors have kept
their top leadership close to Islamabad.
The political analysts have been
predicting a worsening of Pak-Taliban
ties since 1997. One way of this
happening could have been the
consolidation of power by the Taliban
with Afghanistan, which thy still have
not achieved. Another way would be for
the Pakistanis themselves to turn against
Taliban as has happened now by siding
with America and lending their air bases
to them. Some say Pervez Musharraf is
playing a double game by deploying
Mujahideens to fight againt the
Americans.
The Pak
rulers and ISI agencies not only
destroyed Afghanistan by supporting
Taliban but also tried to play the same
game in Kashmir but they forgot that
Kashmir is a part of secular and
democratic India. The youth in Kashmir
who were misled and trained on the
pattern of Taliban realised very soon
they were deceived by Pakistan rulers.
Many of them surrendered and joined
national stream. Pakistan has disowned
Taliban whose boat seems to be sinking.
Now the Kashmiris should also think
seriously whether the Pak rulers are
really their friends or foes. The fate of
the Taliban is before them. A couplet
from renowned Urdu poet Mirza Ghalib is
an eye opener ''HUYE TUM DOST JIS KE
DUSHMAN USKA ASMAN KYON HO'' (Meaning
that if you become somebody's friend, he
does not need heaven's enemity).
|
 |
Need
to boost organic farming
By
Radhakrishna Rao
The havoc
unleashed by high tech farming based on
the widespread and indiscriminate use of
agrochemicals has once again brought into
sharp focus the need to practise farming
in harmony with nature. No wonder, the
pitfalls of the green revolution have led
to a worldwide resurgence in natural
farming that seeks yield from earth
without spoiling the ecosystem at large.
Indeed the much advertised green
revolution, relying on the high yielding,
vulnerable varieties and an abundant
supply of water have failed to ward off
the threat of droughts. Lacking
resistance to insects and nests, and
unable to withstand climatic fluctuations
. The high yielding varieties have turned
out to be no match for the proven natural
varieties.
In fact, a
scientific study by the American National
Academy comes to the conclusion that the,
application of pesticides and fertilisers
does not necessarily lead to better
farming than the natural farming. Perhaps
the credit for putting natural farming on
pratical footing an a global scale goes
to Japanese plant pathologist Fukuoks who
secured an FAO award for the signal
service rendered to the cause of natural
farming. A staunch believer in the
principles of Zen Buddhism, Fukuoke says
that his regenerate itself. Fukuoks is
clear in his perception that the
soils nourishing qualities stem
from organic matter that return to soil
periodically.
The world
over organically- grown farm produce is
gaining in popularity among the health
and quality-conscious consumers to reduce
dependence on non- renewable energy
sources and realise the full efficiency
of inputs and economic realisation of
yields. Studies reveal that by adopting
natural and sustainable farming methods,
India can produce as much as 100-million
of additional foodgrains.
According
to Dr Teuro Higs, agricultural scientist
and a staunch advocate of nature farming,
the concept of nature farming seeks to
re-establish the balance of energy in
nature without using pesticides and
chemicals. "This ancient technique
of nature farming is based on sound
ecological principles", says Dr
Hifs. No wonder, nature farming is
becoming popular in both the developed
north and developing south.
In Tamil
Nadu's Dharampuri district, a progressive
farmer V R K Murthy has obtained
spectacular resultsby integrating
traditional farming practices with
scientific techniques. According to
murthy, intercropping is an insurance
against crop failures. If one crop fails,
one always has another to rely on, says
Murthy.
Narayana
Reddy, a farmer with a ten acre farm in
Sorhunase hamlet near Bangalore, is
another staunch votary of organic farming
methods. Several farmers, scientists and
researchers with an active interest in
organic farming gather at his farm where
they are advised not to be concerned over
the stiff raise in prices of fertilizers
and pesticides. Says Reddy, "Indian
agriculture should seize the opportunity
to bid adieu to synthetic fertilizers and
adopt farming methods that make use of
organic manure.''
Since
Reddys farm is located close to Sai
Baba's monastry at Whitefield, the
farmers organic farming methods
have received plenty of international
exposure from tourists.
Reddy has
already trained many farmers in and
around his village in the technique of
organic farming. He points out that
farmers can switch over to organic
farming gradually over a period of five
years by stopping application of
chemicals to a quarter of their land each
year.
However,
Reddy cautions that in the initial
stages, the yield will be less for it
takes time for the soil to adjust itself
to the changes brought about by changing
over from fertilizers to organic manures.
Reddy
stresses that organic manure do not
destroy earthwormsthe true friends
of farmers. According to Reddy, the
presence of earthworms is vital as it
increases nitrogen, potassium and
phosphorous contents in the soil. Reddy
states that farmers can not only a manage
without using fertilizers and pesticides
but have no real need for them.
PTI feature
|
|
RBI's
monetary and credit policy
By K R Sudhaman
The Reserve
Banks Credit Policy has had mixed
reactions. While the industry, hit hard by the
economic slowdown feels RBI Governor Bimal Jalan
could have done much more, Government
particularly Finance Minister Yashwant Sinha has
described it as bold and forward looking aimed at
spurring growth by infusing much needed
liquidity. But there is no denying the fact it is
a pragmatic response to the difficult situation
that the economy is facing.
The new credit
policy cuts the bank rate by 0.5 per cent,
reduces the CRR from an effective 6.3 per cent to
5.25 per cent two stages and raises interest paid
on CRR to the full bank rate of 6.5 per cent. The
reduction in CRR by 200 basis points as much
beyond expectation by the markets. This is
expected to ease the liquidity by about Rs 8000
crore. Considering the recessionary trends world
over and the recent unprecedented global events,
these measures will certainly help in pump
priming.
In the face of
unfavourable industrial and export situation, RBI
has reduced the GDP growth target for the current
fiscal to 5-6 per cent from its earlier
projections of 6-6.5 per cent. It is in this
background, RBI claims to have adopted a pro-
growth approach in the policy. But considering
that the economic fundamentals are strong with
moderate inflation, stable and low interest
rates, comfortable foreign exchange reserves of
45 billion dollars and large foodgrain stocks,
one is not wrong in saying that Jalan could have
been more bold in the credit policy. Perhaps
having served in Government for long, it appears
he chose to be cautious even as he took some
steps forward.
There is no
denying the fact that Indian interest rates have
been reduced by less than in most of the
developing countries in the present circumstances
and CRR remains among the highest in the world.
With inflation at 3.2 per cent, the real prime
lending rate at 7 per cent will certainly act as
a dampener to attract investment, which is the
need of the hour to kickstart the economy. The
complaint of the Industry that Jalan has done too
little too late is not totally out of place.
One good thing he
has done by cutting bank rate by 50 basis points
is that he has helped the Government, which is
perhaps the largest borrower. With fiscal deficit
likely to mount in the face of huge shortfall of
revenue collections by about Rs 30,000 to Rs
35,000 crore, the Government borrowing is
expected to shoot up, much beyond the targeted Rs
116,000 crore for the financial year. As it is
there are indications that the borrowing has
touched nearly 80 per cent of the budgeted level
in just six months. So any cut in bank rate will
help the Government as it would reduce its
interest burden marginally, which stood at around
Rs 100,000 crore annually.
On CRR there are
some criticisms that it is not exactly two per
cent. Effectively it is only 0.8 per cent,
releasing about Rs 8,000 crore in two tranches of
Rs 6,000 crore and Rs 2,000 crore on Nov 3 and
Dec 29. This coupled with increase in interest
rate on eligible CRR balance at best will make a
difference of a few basis points in terms of
reduction in reserve-adjusted cost of funds.
There are also
fears that the additional liquidity provided
might find itself in undesirable avenues in the
absence of fiscal impulse. So it is all the more
important that the Government provide the
necessary fiscal stimulus. Jalan has now shown
the way and it is now for the Vajpayee Government
to act. RBI has taken some risk though not
adequately and the Government should respond to
spur growth and investment by pushing up much
needed public expenditure.
The cut in
interest rate will impact on prices of financial
assets, especially bonds and equities. The
financial market is far from integrated with the
rest of the market. Financial intermediation
business in the country is dominated by Public
Sector Banks and Financial Institutions. Hence
responses to changes in interest rate are not
forthcoming in the equities market. It would have
helped further if RBI had relaxed the cap on the
Capital Market exposure and introduced increased
supervision on this part of the Banks
portfolio. This would have lifted the morale of
the equity market.
There are some
sops for the exporters. The policy has advised
reduction in the ceiling on interest rate on
rupee export credit by one percentage point
across the board for six months. Jalan claims
that the effective interest costs on six month
export credit is only 3-4 per cent. But exporters
feel they still have an uncompetitive credit
structure, more so in the present global
uncertainties. The only silver lining is that
Jalan promised to look into exporters demands by
making study with the help of NCAER.
In some the major
benficiary is the Government as its cost of
borrowing would be less. Besides Government's
interest outflow would fall considerably in the
background of the prevailing poor credit offtake.
The worst affected will however be the senior
citizens- the retired persons and pensioners who
do not have social security schemes that match up
to those in develolped countries.
PTI Feature
|
Children's
literature in Hindi
By Damodar Agrawal
There is a lot of
activity in the world of childrens
literature in Hindi. So much so that it looks
like a golden age. Though there is a dearth of
magazines for children, there are about 500
writers regularly writing for them and publishing
about the same number of books every year. By the
Hindi Akademi of Delhi and NCERT they are being
regularly awarded prizes.
Major participants
in the activity are National Book Trust, the
Childrens Book Trust and the Publications
Division of the Information Ministry. Others
include private publishers, the Bal Bhawan
Society, Delhis Hindi Akademi, the NCERT,
Bal Kalyan Sansthan (Kanpur), the Bharatiya
Bhasha Parishad (Calcutta) and the Hindi
academies of some state governments.
In addition, the
All India Radio, Delhi, and the regional radio
stations regularly broadcast literary programmes
for children.
Yet the
writers and publishers, interest in
children's literature seems to be ad hoc and
half-hearted. They pursue this as a
side-business. During the years of the operation
black-board scheme, thousands of books were
written and publishedbecause it was supposed to
be a commercial venture.
But when the
scheme flopped, credit NBT, there was a lull in
the trade. Publishers now shudder to invest money
on childrens books.
Childrens
writers are treated in low esteem. Awards for
childrens literature fetch the lowest
amount of money. In 1994, Delhis Hindi
Akedemi announced no award, and the awards
distributed earlier were limited to Rs.2,000. The
highest annual award of Rs. 10,000 is given by
the NCERT, but only two Hindi writers get it. The
Bharatendu Harishchandra Puraskar- has extended
its scope to cover childrens literature.
But, unfortunately, no writer was considered fit
for the first and second prizes. The winner of
the third prize only got Rs.3,000.
Though the
quantity of literature being produced every year
is not very discouraging, the quality leaves much
to be desired. That is because of the lip-service
paid to this genre. The emphasis of the National
Book Trust, the biggest public sector publisher,
is on the publication of utilitarian literature,
which includes biographs and informative
material, which is a set-back to original
creative writers.
The NCERT has
confined itself to textbooks. The Publications
Divisions does not publish poetry, though it has
started bringing out story books.
Even otherwise,
the writers for children are divided between two
steel-framed loyalty groups led by Harikrishna
Devasare on the one hand, and Jai Prakash Bharati
on the other.
The one preaches
the modern scientific and psychological approach
and the other is a votary of fancies, fairies and
myths.
There is also a
third group called the Kanpur Syndrome led
by Dr. Rashtra Bandhu, which specialises in the
production of poetry for self-glorification.
Their monthly Bal Sahitya Sameek shall
trades in idolatry and iconoclasticism, apart
from giving the prestigious Rs. 500 annual
puraskars to the best writers.
The scenario is
darkened further by the dearth of good
childrens magazines. Bennet Colemans
"Parag" was closed years ago. The only
childrens magazine that continues to win
the little hearts is Hindustan
Timess Nandan and Rajasthan Patrikas
Balhans. Though their circulation at present is
nearly a quarter of a million, they fail to reach
even two per cent of the Hindi- speaking families
in Delhi and Jaipur from where they are
published.
Other magazines,
Champak and Suman Saurabh by Delhi Press, are
lacking in literary content, though they are
quite popular.
The All India
Radio with its huge network in the Hindi-belt
could have done a lot to boost literature for
children. But the production for the
childrens slot has always been in the hands
of the immature and the inexperienced.
After the
retirement of Balak Ram Nagar, for example, the
radio "Bal-Karyakram" has suffered a
setback. It has lost its poetry and originality.
The Hindi
newspapers are not contributing much towards
improving the quality of childrens
literature, though in their Sunday editions they
are devoting enough space to it. The stories and
poems that they publish are mostly of ephemeral
interest written as they are to suit particular
festivals and occasions. Yet the contribution of
Parag and Dharmyug cannot be ignored.
The credit for
establishing childrens poetry as a separate
entity goes to them, though they are now defunct.
If there is a
deterioration in quality, this is due also to the
tendency of the big writers to spurn and look
down upon those who write exclusively for
children. This is not to say that there is a
total blackout. Away from hype and hoopla, there
are many who are writing well and writing
substantially.
If a proper
evaluation of the "Hindi' Bal Sahitya' has
to be done it should be on the strength of their
writings only. The rest is worth ignoring.
PTI Feature
|
 |
Seeds
of new cold war
By K. V. S. Rama Sarma
A new cold war is
taking birth in the strife-torn Afghanistan. The
American bombs that are killing innocent people
and flattening towns and villages, may or not
help the cause for which Washington launched the
attacks more than two weeks back, but they are
creating a fertile ground for a clash of
interests among nations that are directly or
indirectly connected with Afghanistan. Whether
the war is long or short, the fire that was
ignited by the attacks on the World Trade Centre
in New York and Pentagon in Washington is
unlikely to end soon. The US has correctly
perceived these two ghastly incidents to be
declaration of war on the same lines as
Pearl Harbour attack - and responded as any self
respecting nation would and should do.
It is foolish to
imagine that Master Militant Osama bin Laden and
his protective cover Taliban would not have
anticipated the American response. And it is
equally naive to believe that Pakistan, which was
infact the lifeline of the Taliban -bin Laden
axis, was not part of the grand advance
preparations to face the expected American wrath.
Since the American diplomatic and strategic
reflexes and responses are stereotyped and are
known, the Taliban -Pak nexus must have made
adequate planning to take advantage of the rugged
topography of Afghanistan and the deadly winter
months. It is entirely possible that the attacks
in New York and Washington were timed for
September keeping in mind the possibility of
American response to come in pre winter months
and Ramzan fasting period.
If the Americans
go on as promised by Secretary of State Colin
Powell, ignoring Gen. Musharraf's plea to recess
bombing during the Ramzan month, the Muslim
opinion all over the world will become
increasingly more strident and anti-American.
And, continued U.S. armed action will take the
war into the winter months posing serious
logistical problems for the Americans. Apart from
the missile attack the U.S. had launched
following the militant attack on its embassy in
Kenya, which gave a very good idea of the ways of
the American war machine. Taliban also knows the
American thinking quite well since both had
collaborated closely to fight the Russians. Non
partisan reports from Afghanistan indicate that
the U.S. bombing has not suffered any damage at
all.
Barring civilian
deaths and destruction of private houses and a
few public buildings the U.S. bombing has not
been able to inflict the expected blow to Taliban
let alone cripple its war machine. Reports say
that life is going on an usual and Talibans
military helicopters are flying on their routine
rounds. As Taliban has said repeatedly it is
waiting for U.S. foot soldiers. The commandos the
U.S has dropped in Northern Afghanistan are
reported to have withdrawn after a few hours!
Equally inspiring are the reports about the
Northern Alliance, which apparently has not made
any headway at all. No direct contact or
confrontation has taken place between the two
warring Afghan factions so far.
The Americans have
made it clear that they would not like to provide
air cover to Northern Alliance troops without
which real thrust towards Kabul is not possible.
Talibans forces are estimated at 80,000 to
85,000. Having learnt the art of fighting a big
and better -equipped army during their wars with
the Russian Red Army, Taliban would know how to
deploy its limited troops and firepower to
maximum advantage against the Americans. The
elusive Taliban has already compelled U.S.
Defence Secretary Rumsfeld to admit that U.S.
forces may not be able to catch Osama. Given this
pessimistic outlook, the U.S. campaign in
Afghanistan seems to be going nowhere just as the
Northern Alliance too seems to moving in rounds
with no one coming along to help.
It is this
stalemate and consequent frustration that will
foment clash of interests leading to a new cold
war. Perhaps anticipating this operational
deadlock the Americans have begun talking about
post-Taliban regime prematurely. Clearly they
want to find a political alternative to military
action. That not only would save the face of the
Americans, especially President Bush, but will
also give them a foothold in the geographically
crucial Afghanistan, which is situated at a vital
trijunction of Asia. Upto here all the players in
the game - Pakistan, Russia, Central Asian
Republics, China and India - have no objections.
The problems arise
if Americans try to foist a government of their
choice creating a Southern Alliance. Already
Secretary Powell has unceremoniously rejected
Gen. Musharrafs idea of imposing on Kabul a
pro-Pak regime. Now that the U.S. has exposed its
mind, Gen. Musharraf will begin playing the old
Pakistani game of double -dealing. The capture
and execution of moderate veteran Afghan leader
Abdul Haq by Taliban, foiling the attempts of
American helicopters and gunships to rescue him
does not augur well for efforts to cobble up a
compromise regime to replace Taliban. It is a
clear warning to Washington and others that
Taliban overtly and Pakistan covertly will not
permit the present Kabul regime to be changed
peacefully. Pakistans idea of a regime
pliable to its own interests is bond to become
the bone of contention dividing the powers
involved into different camps.
If the war goes on
as at present producing no worthwhile results,
the U.S. may willy-nilly allow itself to be
persuaded by Gen. Musharraf to accept a new
Taliban regime -old wine in new bottle - on the
understanding that Osama wil halt his tirade
against Washington. If this means some adjustment
in Middle East, the U.S. will not hesitate to
agree. The crude manner the U.S. has been trying
to rein in Israel gives an inkling of
Pentagons thinking.
If Pakistan
brokers peace between the U.S. and Taliban, all
the three can hope to dominate Central Asia and
its natural resources and exert enormous
political pressure on others. What must be
remembered is that the fundamental cause for U.S.
- Islamic conflict in Palestine. Since the
American civilization, prestige and power are at
stake it should not be a surprise if the U.S.
comes up with a compromise solution to bring
peace in Middle East - In such a scenario, the
possibility of Islamic military being diverted to
other regions like Kashmir in India, Sinkiang in
China and Chechnya in Russia cannot be and should
not be ruled out. That would herald a new
cold war. CNF
|
 |
|