EDITORIAL

UNENTHUSIASTIC MUSHARRAF

The Prime Minister, Atal Behari Vajpayee, has failed. Pakistan’s Chief Executive, Gen. Parvez Musharraf, has succeeded. Vajpayee’s failure to make Gen. Musharraf jump up in ecstasy by his invitation to him for talks in New Delhi. And Gen. Musharraf’s success in making Vajpayee and his men wait for his formal reply to the invitation. The reply, amazingly, did not arrive in New Delhi even after the conclusion of a "big" event on May 28. The event: Jaswant Singh, Minister for External Affairs, played host to a major exercise in public relations where more than 300 journalists spent over four hours having lunch and attending the prolonged question-answer session at a five-star hotel. When India formally extended an invitation to Gen. Musharraf and his wife to visit Delhi for talks, Vajpayee and his colleagues in the BJP-led NDA coalition obviously expected a prompt reply from Pakistan’s Chief Executive. Gen. Musharraf, suddenly, chose to be unenthusiastic. He also chose to keep the Indian leaders guessing, even after the invitation was handed over to him on May 25. Of course, he commissioned men like his Foreign Minister, Abdus Sattar, and Foreign Secretary, Inamul Haq, to talk about "favourable" response from Islamabad ...more

Exim policy 2001-2002

By K R Sudhaman
The Exim Policy, an annual fea- ture which is unveiled on March 31 every year was more or less on expected lines as it opened up the Indian Economy to foreign consumer goods including automobiles, white goods and.....
more

Media and literature -
Roles & relationship

By G S Rajamani
According to the Webster's Encyclopaedic Dictionary, ''Media - also called as Mass Media-- refers to the means of communication as radio and .....
more

Kshir Bhawani,
the merciful mother

By Prof. O. N. Chrungoo
The State of Jammu & Kashmir has been the abode of geat rishis who have invited and invoked all the great tirthas of India in this State. Tirthas like ....
more

Malnourishment
deaths in Maharashtra

By Sweta Patwardhan
Calling it a belated response in an understatement. For the malnutrition deaths in Maharashtra had stared people in the face....
more

EDITORIAL

UNENTHUSIASTIC MUSHARRAF

The Prime Minister, Atal Behari Vajpayee, has failed. Pakistan’s Chief Executive, Gen. Parvez Musharraf, has succeeded. Vajpayee’s failure to make Gen. Musharraf jump up in ecstasy by his invitation to him for talks in New Delhi. And Gen. Musharraf’s success in making Vajpayee and his men wait for his formal reply to the invitation. The reply, amazingly, did not arrive in New Delhi even after the conclusion of a "big" event on May 28. The event: Jaswant Singh, Minister for External Affairs, played host to a major exercise in public relations where more than 300 journalists spent over four hours having lunch and attending the prolonged question-answer session at a five-star hotel. When India formally extended an invitation to Gen. Musharraf and his wife to visit Delhi for talks, Vajpayee and his colleagues in the BJP-led NDA coalition obviously expected a prompt reply from Pakistan’s Chief Executive. Gen. Musharraf, suddenly, chose to be unenthusiastic. He also chose to keep the Indian leaders guessing, even after the invitation was handed over to him on May 25. Of course, he commissioned men like his Foreign Minister, Abdus Sattar, and Foreign Secretary, Inamul Haq, to talk about "favourable" response from Islamabad to New Delhi’s offer of talks. But he himself avoided making any formal comment on Vajpayee’s communication after it was delivered to him. Pakistan’s High Commissioner in India, Ashraf Jehangir Qazi, was also mandated by his bosses to make public somewhat inconvenient points for New Delhi, such as a plebiscite for Kashmir, Islamabad’s undiminished attachment to the UN Security Council resolutions on Kashmir and the ‘relevance’ of Kashmir’s All-Party Hurriyat Conference (APHC) as the representative body of the Kashmiri people. It really looked like a well-coordinated exercise between Islamabad and the Delhi-based Pak chancery, with Jehangir Qazi adopting the pro-Hurriyat Conference posture and Abdus Sattar maintaining that the Kashmir issue would figure "prominently" at the proposed summit meeting between Vajpayee and Gen. Musharraf. On his way back from the extraordinary session of the Organisation of Islamic Conference (OIC), Pakistan’s Foreign Minister told a news conference in Peshawar that while Pakistan had a "historical and categorical" stand on the "core issue" of Kashmir, Islamabad was not for a "Camp David-like agreement" at the proposed summit in New Delhi. Jaswant Singh seemed to have been provoked by certain utterings of Abdus Sattar and Ashraf Jehangir, and, hence, was forced to call a spade a spade at his press conference. While Islamabad’s official line is that Kashmir is a disputed territory, Jaswant Singh has chosen to reiterate that Jammu and Kashmir is "an integral part" of India and the position endorsed by Parliament through a resolution "remains unaltered". And as he opposed the talk of a plebiscite in J&K, Jaswant said that Indian Parliament had stated that the "whole of Jammu and Kashmir is an integral part of India" and that the Government was "a servant of Parliament". A day earlier, on May 27, Abdus Sattar , who is known to weigh every word he speaks, emphasized that there "is no shift" in Pakistan’s policy on Kashmir. In fact, he vehemently denied the notion that Islamabad had any plan to settle the dispute ignoring the Kashmiri people and leaders. Significantly, at a time when Jaswant Singh was fielding questions at his news conference ranging from the proposed dialogue with Pakistan to the appointment of a Chief of Defence Staff, Gen. Musharraf, instead of realising the need for a prompt reply to Vajpayee’s invitation letter, engaged himself in the celebrations in connection with the third anniversary of Pakistan becoming a nuclear power in rivalry with India. Gen. Musharraf call to his country’s scientists: Broaden the base of their research work. Two signals came in from Pakistan after Jaswant Singh’s blunt statements. First, the hard-liners in Pak Armed Forces voiced reservations on New Delhi’s real intentions. Second, the message was allowed to got out that the comments made by Indian Foreign-cum-Defence Minister, particularly on the Kashmir issue, were bound to complicate matters for the Musharraf regime. Jaswant Singh, obviously, had little option bu to come out openly on the Kashmir issue after the Pakistani Foreign Minister struck a hawkish posture at his press conference in Peshawar. The two news conferences, one in Peshawar followed by another in New Delhi a day later, clearly brought out the difficulties ahead in making any meaningful progress in the relations between India and Pakistan. Jaswant Singh’s assertions, one can anticipate at this stage, will, in the coming days and weeks, lead to louder voices from hawks and hard-liners in Pakistan. By the time Jaswant Singh reiterated the finality of Kashmir’s accession to the Indian Union, certain extremist outfits in Pakistan, including Lashkar-e-Toiba and Al Badr and Jamaat-e-Islami, urged the Musharraf Government to make it clear to the Government of India that Islamabad would settle for nothing less than grant of self-determination to the Kashmiris. Pakistan-based Hizbul Mujahideen supremo, Syed Salahuddin, also chose May 28 to make public his prediction: Gen. Musharraf’s talks with Atal Behari Vajpayee will not be fruitful. His prediction is based on his oft-repeated assertion: Kashmiris are basic party to the Kashmir problem and without their participation, talks on the issue will be futile. That Salahuddin does not want Gen. Musharraf to travel to New Delhi for talks has been explained by his verdict: "There is no sincerity in the Indian offer. On the one hand, Vajpayee ended the cease-fire, and on the other he invited Gen. Musharraf for talks". The likes of Salahuddin and Hafiz Mohammed Saeed, chief of the Lashkar-e-Toiba, would have appreciated if New Delhi had further extended the cease-fire period in Kashmir, simply because it would have served their strategic move of further expanding and strengthening anti-India cadres and building stocks of arms and ammunition not only in the Valley but also in the sensitive districts of Jammu region. Why did the Vajpayee Government suddenly decide to engage Pakistan’s Chief Executive in talks? It can be said safely that so far no attempt has been made to outline the reasons in this regard. True, Washington was found building pressure on New Delhi and Islamabad to resume the stalled dialogue process between the two sides. But, at the same time-and, indeed, significantly-the US President, George W Bush did offer his "advice" that Pakistan should create an atmosphere conducive for dialogue. There was no need for George Bush to point out that Vajpayee’s oft-repeated assertion that Islamabad should end the cross-border terrorism before any talks between the two countries was, unfortunately, ignored by the defiant, belligerent military Government in Islamabad. And can Vajpayee deny that under his regime, Pakistan-backed terrorism has metamorphosed from a hit-and-run drive to direct, deadly assaults on security camps? At a time when many in India and Pakistan as well as in New Delhi’s power corridors had expected New Delhi to stick to its commitment not to open dialogue with the Pak military junta until it halted its support to terrorism in Jammu and Kashmir, Vajpayee’s move jettisoning his commitment by extending an invitation to the military ruler for talks, obviously, shocked the opponents of terrorism and its sponsors across the Indian borders. It can also be argued that the mood itself becomes an important factor before any major event-like the proposed summit between Vajpayee and Gen. Musharraf-is allowed to take place. Unfortunately, the mood seems to have been vitiated by Pak statements on Kashmir and counter statements on the issue by New Delhi.

Exim policy 2001-2002

By K R Sudhaman

The Exim Policy, an annual fea- ture which is unveiled on March 31 every year was more or less on expected lines as it opened up the Indian Economy to foreign consumer goods including automobiles, white goods and fruits and vegetables with the total dismantling of the quantitative restrictions from April one this year.

Both Finance Minister Yashwant Sinha and Commerce and Industry Minister Murasoli Maran, have repeatedly said the fears of the Indian Industry that the phase-out of quantiative restrictions would open the floodgates to cheap imports is unfounded.

They often quoted statistics to say that ever-since the process of dismantling of QRs started in 1996, there has been no surge in imports and 2000-01 in particular the non-oil imports recorded a negative eight per cent growth despite withdrawal of QRs in 714 items in April last year. This year QRs were lifted in the remaining 715 items to adopt the system of tariffication.

If one goes by statistics, one would not be wrong in concluding that the industry's fear is grossly exaggerated and that crying horse is an attempt to cover up the inefficiency of the Indian Industry by denying consumers value for money by allowing cheap imports.

There is no denying the fact that Indian Industry should gear up to face competition especially with gloablisation, which is unstoppable. But at the same time it is also true that conducive atmosphere is yet to be created for the Indian Industry to take on global competition as realities on the ground are far from satisfactory.

For instance cost of borrowing is still very high as compared to international standards with interest rates hovering in the double digits despite Reserve Bank's efforts in the last few years to move on to lower rates. All thes show there are enough mechanisms available to protect domestic industries and farming community which is the backbone of the Indian economy. But the fact remains that domestic industry may be protected from the onslaught of imports but it could become competitive only if congenial environment is created for which government should act swiftly.

The Exim policy does contain some measure in this regard like giving a major role for the state governments for the first time in export promotion activities by making a provision of Rs 100 crore in the budget. Also it provides for a market access initiative to assist industry with produce and country specific focus.

The policy also streamlines and simplifies procedures to encourage exports, which have achieved 20 per cent growth in 2000-01 as against 11 per cent in the previous year. The 10-12 Special Economic Zone developers are to get infrastructure status besides allowing foreign Direct Investment in SEZ under automatic route for all manufacturing sectors.

All these measures are expected to take India's exports to 75 billion dollars annually in three years from the present level of 47 billion dollars. In the next five years Government proposes to take India's share in world trade to one per cent from the present level of 0.6 per cent.

One fear of the Indian automobile industry that allowing import of cars and two wheelers including second hand cars in the exim policy would lead to dumping is misplaced. They argue that Indian automobile industry, which has investment of Rs 50,000 crore will be in doldrums with the imports of cars and two wheelers. As one is aware Finance Minister has already raised duty on second hand cars to 180 per cent and basic duty on new cars and two wheelers to 60 per cent.

Besides there are other stipulations like Left-hand drive cars could not be imported and that second hand cars could not be more than three years old. Also imports of cars could be only through designated ports. All these would act as deterrent as imports of automobiles would become cost-prohibitive.

Sinha is right in saying that Indian automobile industry is uncompetitive even after 110 per cent total interest rate regime. Also there are any number of infrastructure bottlenecks like power shortage and high power tariffs for industrial use and high waiting period in ports. The waiting period in ports is 6 to 7 days as against six to seven hours in Singapore or Hong Kong. Besides Indian Ports' capacity and container han dling facility are so dismal that 60 per cent of revenue at Colombo Port are generated by handling of Indian Containers. This being the scenario one wonders how could Indian Industry become competitive to meet the global challenges when Government is not in a position to address the concerns of the Industry. So there is some validity in Industry's demand that the opening-up of the Indian Market to foreign goods should be accompanied by creation of necessary environment for Indian Industry to face the competition. Otherwise cheap imported consumer goods flooding the market would spell death-knell for the Indian Industry.

While Government argues that Indian Industry should become competitive, it also asserts that it would protect domestic industries and farming community at all costs by raising tariffs on certain commodities to the bound levels particularly agricultural products.

It is precisely for this reason that a standing group of secretaries of Commerce, Revenue, SSI and ARI, Animal Husbandry and Director General of Foreign Trade has been set up to function as a ''War-room'' for tracking, collating and analysing data on 300 sensitive items which are important to the public.

Every month the government will publish a monthly statement in the media about import-status of the 300 items. This will act as an early warning system. The monitoring of imports has already been streamlined and the statistics in respect of all the 10202 tariff lines are now available with a time lag of 2-3 months as against 10-12 months earlier. The gap is to be reduced further. Also other mechanisms are available like anti-dumping measures. Besides imports of items like wheat, rice, maize petrol, diesel, ATF and urea will be permitted only through the designated state trading enterprises. Duty on new vehicles and 180 per cent duty on second-hand cars, then there is something wrong and it was time they took corrective measures.

On the whole the exim policy does contain far-reaching measures to boost exports and help industry to gear itself to the challenges of globalisation. But what is important is that both the Government and Industry should take steps on a war-footing to remove infrastructure bottlenecks and upgrade technology to face competition as otherwise India would be left behind in the world trade. PTI Feature

Media and literature - Roles & relationship

By G S Rajamani

According to the Webster's Encyclopaedic Dictionary, ''Media - also called as Mass Media-- refers to the means of communication as radio and television, newspapers, magazines etc. that reach very large number of population''. It may be seen that the crux of the definition of media refers to its reach to the large audience.

By this definition, in a modern day, perhaps we may have to include the internet services around the world where the websites offer various kinds of literature and information to the global audience. Now we may turn to the meaning of literature itself. Webster's Dictionary covers a wide range of writings which would fall within the generic term called literature. According to Webster's Dictionary, literature means :

''Writings in which expression and form in connection with ideas of permanent and universal interest are characteristic or essential features as poetry, history, biography, essays etc.''

A further embellishment of literature deals with ''belleslettres'. Letters refer to artistic writing worthy of being remembered. In the broadest sense, literature includes any type of writings on any subject, for example, the literature of medicine. Usually, however, the term means the body of artistic writing of a country or period which are characterised by beauty of expression and form and by universality of intellectual and emotional appeal.

The basic definitions of media and literature as brought out above would indicate a variety of angles in which a literature could be handled by any kind of media and it also indicates the variety of literature handled by a particular medium.

The subject of the relationship between the two becomes, therefore, complex in itself. In view of the vastness of the subject, it would be useful to review the media and literature in the contemporary world with a view to identifying specific issues which need to be consciously looked into for improving the handling of the literature by the media so that the vast audience that the media commands would be in a position to have a proper kind of appreciation of literature which would also have a didactic angle in the matter.

Literature incorporates two essential ingredients in its structure-ideas, or substance or content on the one hand and the Scientists by virtue of the training, give importance to the substance and very often they look for brevity of expression. However, a man of literature which not ignoring ideas, would pay considerable attention to the language in which the ideas are expressed. While the substance of a subject satisfies the intellectual appetite, the language has an appeal on emotional side. Ideas, in a sense, are matters of head, whereas the language is more often a matter of the heart. A good literature is one which strikes a balance between the two, i.e. the language on the one hand and the ideas on the other. Media should pay attention to the need for balanced literature and should consciously propogate the value of a balance in literature. This could be done by analysing the contemporary literature including the new books which indicates this balance would also be a message for the authors that they should aim at balancing between the language and ideas in writing books.

A criticism which is very often heard about the media is that they allocate more time or space to subjects of temporary interests. It is true that the press or the television allocates more of space and time respectively for the subject which have a sensational angle.

The American Spacecraft landing on the Mars was not given the wide publicity because of its limited appeal. It also lacked the sensational because Mars lander failed to send signals back to NASA. One would have expected a detailed discussion on the efforts to land on the Mars and reasons as to why the machine failed. That would have had an educational value.

Should there not be the responsibility for the media to balance the time between items of temporary interests and those of lasting values. Media has a task to build responsible public opinion and build interests of people in areas of abiding value to the people in the long run by disseminating information in an impartial and objective manner.

If we recognise the fact that the media has the responsibility in building public opinion on the right lines, then we should also recognise the need for shifting the literature and bring out the best out of the available literature. There is an area which needs a special handling. This pertains to the category called the young writers or first timers. Media has to be sensitive to the emerging literature. There is a need to give publicity to the positive aspects of literature which would motivate others to proceed on right lines.

Indian media has unfortunately been characterised by conspicuous absence of internal recognition of Indian literature. History has shown that if the Indians have become great in certain fields, it is not because of the recognition by the Indian media. In most cases, the people have been recognised as great because of the external recognition, that is, from outside the country.

Rabindranath Tagore might not have been remembered but for the Nobel Prize for Literature. Dr S Radhakrishnan, who was President of India, is remembered as a great Philosopher because the West recognised him. Dr C V Raman is known for the ''Raman Effect'' but he became famous only after he received Nobel Prize for Physics. The great Mathematician Srinivasa Ramanujam would have died as an unknown clerk of the Port Trust, Madras but for the fact that his Mathematical abilities were recognised by Professor Hardy of UK Dr Chandra Shekhar is known as eminent Astrophysicist because of the recognition by the Nobel Committee and by American Government. A Space Research Centre in the USA has recently been named after him.

More recently, we have a number of Indian authors such as Vikram Seth, Arundati Roy, Jhumpa Lahiri etc, who have become famous because of the recognition abroad. Even the eminent novelist R K Narayan became famous only after another eminent western novelist Graham Greene praised him.

The media, will have to be a trend setter of modern norms in the society. At the same time, the media have also a responsibility for revival of the ancient values which have a relevance in the modern day. In fact, the credit for bringing out the Mathematical content in the Vedas goes to the western institutions which have introduced Vedic Mathematics as a curriculum. Many of the logarithms used in the computer programming had, in a sense, been anticipated in the Vedic mathematics itself. Of late, cardiologists throughout the world have been streesing the values of mediation and yoga as form of medicine for treating heart conditions and to handle problems of hypertension.

May be the media will have to highlight such values from our own legacy so that modern youngsters understands these values and get influenced by them. This would call for a shift of the media from the position of a pure profit seeker to that a responsible change agent of the society. This would call for a considerable introspection on the part of the media. PTI Feature

Kshir Bhawani, the merciful mother

By Prof. O. N. Chrungoo

The State of Jammu & Kashmir has been the abode of geat rishis who have invited and invoked all the great tirthas of India in this State. Tirthas like Krishen Ganga, Har-mukat Ganga, Vaishnavi Devi, Rajini and so many others.

Every tirtha there has some mystic roots, a story behind it that has been recorded by great rishis in the form of Mahatmaya, Kalhana in Rajtarangni writes "There is not a speck of earth, that is not a tirtha here".

Kshir Bhawani is one of the most powerful shakti peeths, energy centres and a tirtha of Kashmir Valley, situated at Tulamulla 22 kms from Srinagar. This tirtha is the seat of Tripursundari, Maha Rajini Bhagwati the highest Swatwik, Vaishinavi swarupa of para-shakti.

The detailed account of Kshir Bhawani, Rajini Bhagwati Tirtha at Tulamulla is recorded by Bringesh Rishi in his book Bringesh - Samhita, Bringesh Rishi was a great scholar of Sanskrit from south Kashmir. Bringee village and Bringee nala (tributary river) is today also known after his name. It is here that Bringesh rishi compiled his voluminous Granth Bringeesh Samhita.

Bringesh Samhita contains mythological, spiritual, religious and Tantric backgrounds regarding different tirthas of Kashmir. How many chapters and Mahatmayas it contained, no authentic proof is available because tides of time and upheavals in the Valley of Kashmir destroyed many valuable works of these rishis. However some of the Kashmiri Pandit families have preserved some manuscripts for which much effort and sincere research work is needed to trace and work on them.

It was in the last quarter of nineteenth century that Dr Bhular collected some sixteen Mahatmayas and later M A Stein collected some more and made a list of those collections. Shri Sansar Chand Koul, a great geograppher of Kashmir translated a few, describing them as 'a leaf from Bringisha Samhita'. Rupa Devi Sharda Peetha Trust, Srinagar also published some Mahatmayas from Bringeesh Samhita under the guidance of Prof. K N Dhar, Prem Nath Handoo & Janki Nath Kaul 'Kamal' in nineteen Eighties.

Philosophically explaining the description of any philosophical idea, it has been expressed in a dialogue form between Bharvi & Bharva. Maha-Rajni Pradurbhavah also is in the form of an enquiry dialogue between Bharvi and Bharva.

Bringesha records regarding the appearance of Rajni Bhagwati in Kashmir from Ravana's Lanka, where she was Ravana's Ishtdevi (chief clan diety) under the name of Shyama. At the last death strokes by Rama on Ravana, appeared the Goddess Shyama with wrathful copper-red eyes, smiled a bit and addressed Ravana, "Fie upon you, a degraded demon as you are, I shall forsake you and proceed to my choicest abode in the splendid Himalayas, known as Kashmir - the Satisara, observing vegetarian vow, a Rajni Swarupa (Maha-Rajni Pradurbhavah canto II.58). Lord Rama commanded Hanumana to take charge of the Almighty Goddess and proceed with bestowed serpent-king Ananta, urrounded by three hundred sixty snakes, Hanuman planted the feet of Shri Shyama on his back and arrived in the northern region of Himalaya's Satisara, where the ever-bountiful land is as soft as cotton and thus earned the name of Tulamulyakam (Tulamulla) on having stayed here, she became calm and composed; diet being milk, candy, Kshir and clarified butter, and is worshipped as Maha Rajni Kshir-Bhawani.

Before resting at Tulamulla Shri Rajni Bhagwati touched the sacred 'Pawan' mini Tirtha at Kapalmochan, Lookbhawan, Khanbarni, Lakuth pur, Tekar, Chandigam & Harmukh. If we connect these places in a Geometrical way, it takes the shape of a rosary-bag (known as Zap-Kuthaji in Kashmiri), a sacred yantra according to tantric lore. All these tirthas are powerful sites and equally worshipped by the devotees of Rajni Bhagwati. Since 1992 some Bakhatas under the inspiration of a saintly sadaka Pt. A.D. Veshin have laid foundation of a Kshir Bhawani temple at Bhawani Nagar, Jammu believing the asharwads of Bhagwan Gopinath Ji Maharaj saint of all times -- is with thm.

Bringesha Rishi in Maha Rajni Produrbhava writes ' when Shree Rama ordered Hanumana to carry Tripura Sundari Maha Rajni to Satisar, from the date onwards on every fifteenth day of the bright fortnight of Assuj Shree Rama in the company of Sita undertakes a pilgrimage to Kshir Bhawani in accordance ritual. On the eighth and ninth day of the bright half of the month of Assuj Mundudari and Bibbeshana vissit the shrine respectively. The mighty Hanuman stands guard there for all the time to come.

The main assembly is on eighth day of Zesht Shukla Ashtami, an auspicious day at Kshir Bhawani Bharva says O' Auspicious Bharivi, I have in this way, unfolded to you as to how Goddess Rajni appeared in cosmic form, spring changing colours. By mere listening to this account proficiency of every denomination is achieved (canto II. 72).

Malnourishment deaths in Maharashtra

By Sweta Patwardhan

Calling it a belated response in an understatement. For the malnutrition deaths in Maharashtra had stared people in the face for one too many weeks. Apparently, the state government had chosen to treat children's deaths in the tribal districts of Nandurbar, Nashik and Dhule as a recurring annual phenomenon.

It took a spate of reports in the local media, a bogey of protests raised by the opposition BJP-Shiv Sena alliance and a fairly heavy dose of admonition by Nationalist Congress Party (NCP) founder-president Sharad Pawar for the government to wake up. After costly delays, it finally initiated steps to tide over the acute drought and the consequent unemployment in the three tribal districts of the Nashik revenue division.

Chief Minister Vilasrao Deshmukh even visited the affected areas. Call it sheer coincidence but he set out on the trip on May 9, the day the Supreme Court took serious cognizance of media reports about malnutrition deaths in Nashik division. The public interest litigation (PIL) was filed by the People's Union for Civil Liberties (PUCL). The apex court served notices on the governments of six states, including Maharashtra.

"Sitting in Mumbai, many a time, we do not get a clear picture of what is happening in remote tribal areas. Now, having visited these areas, I have a fair idea," Deshmukh admitted on his return. He also admitted that the tribal welfare and public health departments, despite their effort, had not produced the "desired results."

That the state government is trying to come to grips with the situation in the worst drought-effected Nashik revenue division is borne out by a recent statement by NCP tribal welfare minister Madhukar Pichhad: "The government machinery has started moving after the Chief Minister's visit to these areas." A tribal himself, Pichhad had for some time been crying himself hoarse about the government's laxity in responding to the unchecked malnutrition deaths. He had even complained that despite being a tribal welfare minister, he had not succeeded in getting the act together.

There have been conflicting versions as to the actual number of malnutrition deaths in the three districts. While local media reports have pegged the number of deaths anywhere between 50 and 100, the BJP combine has gone to town, saying that at least 500 children have died in the last few months.

The state administration is yet to compile the number of deaths which took place in April, most of them in Nandurbar district. A senior tribal development official, vaguely, put the figure at 25, eight of which had been diagnosed as malnutrition deaths. Fortunately, no death has been reported since the end of April.

Whatever be the case, one has to take statistics compiled by the Integrated Child Development Service (ICDS) department for 2000-2001 with a pinch of salt. During the year, around 1,385 infants, under a year, died in the three tribal districts because of many reasons, malnutrition being one of them. It has now been officially confirmed that during the same period, an additional 852 children between one and six years of age, succumbed to malnutrition and various viral infections - high fever, pneumonia and diarrhoea.

The state administration does not quite agree that the current situation is alarming, compared to previous years. The officials safely cite infant mortality statistics compiled by the ICDS. According to it, deaths in the tribal areas in the last four years stand at: 1,022 during 1996-97, 1,015 during 1997-98, 1,492 during 1998-99 and 1,148 during 1999-2000.

But what worsens matter is the Chief Minister's attempt to play down the gravity of the situation by saying that the infant mortality rate (IMR) in Maharashtra stood at 48 for every 1,000 children - as against the national average of 70. He has also argued that the IMR had gone down to 35 in Amaravati district's Melghat area after the state government implemented a corrective plan, now known as the "Melghat Pattern" of action. Mr. Deshmukh has promised to adopt the same pattern to curb malnutrition deaths in Nashik revenue division and other tribals pockets in Thane and Ahmednagar. Though the state government had initiated drought relief measures in affected areas last October, execution reports suggest they had fallen grossly short of people's needs. So much so that a large number of people from Nandurbar district migrated to neighbouring Gujrat after the kharif crop failed miserably in October.

One of the reasons for this year's malnutrition deaths has been attributed to the greedy manner in which labour contractors, from the bordering areas of Gujarat, went about recruiting people from Nandurbar district. These contractors paid a lumpsum of Rs 4,000 to 5,000, for the recruiting of one couple for six months. With as many as eight to 12 children, these couples found it difficult to make ends meet. In the end, their children bore the brunt of it all. Though the Vilasrao Dshmukh government has increased the number of jobs available under the state-run Employment Guarantee Scheme (EGS), sunk more bore and tubewells in the Nashik revenue division and regenerated empty private and public wells, it will be quite some time before it can improve public health services. On paper, there are a fairly good number of primary health centres in these rural areas. In reality, most of them lack doctors. Despite being appointed to them, doctors simply refuse to work in remote rural areas. Another problem faced by tribals in remote areas is that they have to trek as much as 20 km to reach a PHC.

The results of the "Melghat Pattern Plan" are still awaited. As part of the plan, the state government supplies foodgrains and drinking water to the affected, caters to the health of malnourished children, creates jobs for their parents and meets children's educational requirements. If the plan for the new area is implemented as effectively as it was in Melghat, the beleaguered tribal population will have something to look forward to. INAV

 



|
home | state | national | business | editorial | advertisement | sports |
|
international | weather | mailbag | suggestions | search |
subscribe | send mail |