EDITORIAL

CONGRESS ROLE

For quite sometime the oldest national party has been suffering from crisis of confidence. Each successive election has resulted in its decline. From a party that ruled the country for 46 years with brute majority and unchallengeable political authority and public support, its strength in current Lok Sabha stands attenuated to 112 MPs. All other parties have grown at the cost of Congress. BJP is comfortably placed from paltry 2 to 182 MPs. Regional parties like DMK and Telugu Desam continue to call the shots in Tamil Nadu and Andhra Pradesh. From ruling party in Tamil Nadu under Kamraj, it has settled for only 15 seats in the ensuing assembly polls in alliance with AIADMK. It cannot hope to win more than 5. In the largest State of Uttar Pradesh it is in total disarray and has . ..more

HURRIYAT REBUFFED

Refusal of UN General Secretary Kofi Annan to grant audience to Hurriyat Leader AG Lone shows how far away is...more

Saint Joseph- patron of work

By P K Joseph Dhar

The entire catholic world comprising about 1.25 billion heads celebrate the feast of St. Joseph on March 19 each year. He was the person to whom an angel of the Lord appeared in a dream who had resolved to divorce Mary as she was found with a child before they had come together, saying; ''Joseph.....more

Perspective on saving
environment

By Dr Navin Chandra Joshi

The annual review of environment 2000, brought out by the world bank, states that more than 20 per cent of the total burden of the explosive rise of various diseases in the Asian region is due to environmental factors.......more

Dealing with Afghanistan

By Fazal Mehmood

Neither the United Nations nor the sanctimonious West has covered itself with glory by showcasing their pusillanimous inaction in the face of the Taliban's criminal operations ......more

EDITORIAL

CONGRESS ROLE

For quite sometime the oldest national party has been suffering from crisis of confidence. Each successive election has resulted in its decline. From a party that ruled the country for 46 years with brute majority and unchallengeable political authority and public support, its strength in current Lok Sabha stands attenuated to 112 MPs. All other parties have grown at the cost of Congress. BJP is comfortably placed from paltry 2 to 182 MPs. Regional parties like DMK and Telugu Desam continue to call the shots in Tamil Nadu and Andhra Pradesh. From ruling party in Tamil Nadu under Kamraj, it has settled for only 15 seats in the ensuing assembly polls in alliance with AIADMK. It cannot hope to win more than 5. In the largest State of Uttar Pradesh it is in total disarray and has been unable to win back the faith of the electorate. In W. Bengal and Kerala it has surrendered the initiative to leftist bandwagon and desperately looking for some moorings. In Bihar it enters into alliance with RJD to play second fiddle to Rabri Devi. One can understand the compulsions and quality of its MLAs as all the 23 MLAs are made Ministers. Nothing could be more ridiculous and suicidal. In the recently held by-elections for 11 assembly seats, it has lost to NDA candidates. The overall scenario is that party has failed to put its act together and continues to go for short-cuts which in turn undermine its credibility in public esteem.

One has to treat Congress Party somewhat differently when compared to other parties. It is still the second largest and to that extent party-in-waiting for the Delhi throne. Without it no combination can hope to capture power. Unfortunately, party is bogged down in petty politics, cheap gimmicks and joining wrong company continues to cause attenuation both at State and Central levels. There is acute dissidence which is major stumbling block. There are too many aspirants for too less seats. Inner party democracy continues to be at a discount as entire decision making is left to the party President Sonia Gandhi. It is as much true even when it comes to selection of candidates for State assemblies, Corporations or even Panchayats. This means none else is competent. This is negation of democracy. The second factor relates to its secular character as also champion of the down-trodden and Dalits/OBCs. In reality it has not been able to please either the minorities or the Dalits. To be precise, it has lost even the upper cast votes. That is why it continues to grope in the dark and opting for short cuts. Third aspect that has caused erosion to its popularity is the lack of clear perspective on vital national issues. It continues to play either side alternatvely and leaving the options wide open. Such dispensation obviously does not sell. Clarity and well-spelt out priorities are essential ingredients to regain popular support of the masses. It indulges in criticism for the sake of criticism which has failed to fetch any dividend to the party fortunes at the husting. In short refusal to function as a responsible and responsive opposition continues to cost the party dearly.

AICC session is on in Bangalore. Some political resolutions provide insight into where things have gone wrong. One resolution seeks reversal of Panchmarhi decision where the party had opted to go single-handed. It is now ready to share power with all secular dispensations. It will be all the more better if Congress goes in for pre-electoral adjustments. Coalition culture is there to stay and no national party can do it on its own. Instead of providing crutches to other miniscules like it did to formation of UF Government, it must give the lead as the largest single opposition party or else wait. Mere anti-BJPism is not going to help it. Likewise, overplaying the minority card is equally counter-productive. There is also the resolution on Kashmir where Congress does not spell how to break the ice but puts the NDA in the dock for mishandling Kashmir issue. It must appreciate that what Congress could not do when it ruled the country with brute majority cannot be done so easily by the coalition Government more so because Kashmir problem owes its birth to wrong policies of the Congress Party right from 1947 onwards. It refuses to go for consensus. Instead it choses to go for blanket criticism. Such thinking needs total reversal because no ready solution is available to solve the Kashmir imbroglio. It was experimental approach right from 1947. It is so even today. There is yet another resolution on liberalisation of economy. Congress rejected socialistic pattern of society and social control from 1991 onwards and opted for liberalisation. This policy yielded good dividends and put the economy back on the rails. It is healthy sign that United Front Govt continued with the policy even as present NDA Government is pursuing second generation reforms quite vigorously. The Congress must come out of narrow cocoons of inhibitive approach and spell out clearly whether it is for liberalisation or not. Karnataka Chief Minister S M Krishana wants Congress to be very clear on its approach and policy. Right now, Congress is neither here nor there. Such confused approach is bad for any national party, more so when it is the party-in-waiting.

The party has neither done any justice to democracy nor to itself by stalling the proceedings of Parliament this time. Prime Minister has already announced comprehensive enquiry into Tehelka.Com expose and promised to spare none found guilty. Congress must not doubt integrity of sitting Supreme Court Judge. That is the farthest any Government can go. If it rejects this enqiry, it shows its lack of faith in judiciary. Further, NDA has decided to seek vote-of-confidence in Lok Sabha when it assembles after almost a week of turmoil and stalled proceedings. Remember, in democracy there are no short-cuts. RJD chief is charge-sheeted in multiple scams. It is in alliance with AIADMK whose chief is likewise heavily scam-tainted. The Bofor kick-back case is in 15th year and yet it is on. Congress Party must understand how democracy functions. It would do real good to the party if it treats every situation on merit rather than go for fish-market politics. After all, it is the 115 year old national party and that too a party-in-waiting.

HURRIYAT REBUFFED

Refusal of UN General Secretary Kofi Annan to grant audience to Hurriyat Leader AG Lone shows how far away is the amalgam from the calculations of United Nations. First, Annan had refused to mediate in Kashmir or go by the UN Resolutions of 1948 for resolving Kashmir issue. Rejection of plebiscite or call it self-determination which has been the favourite theme of Hurriyat is a total setback to the so-called movement. Annan now says 'no' to any meeting with Lone on the plea that there is no time in his three day hectic schedule in New Delhi. Nothing could be more damaging. To be precise, the then American ambassador Frank Wisner during his interaction with Hurriyat leaders in Srinagar had advised the amalgam to contest elections for legitimising its claims of being the sole representative of people of Jammu & Kashmir State. He had also stated that plebiscite is not the only means to ascertain wishes of the people; a fair election is good enough. Subsequently, British MPs and also EU representatives had also advised Hurriyat to try its luck at the husting. Annan's perceptions have thus no place for Hurriyat or its leaders. His stress is on Lahore Declaration which offers fair chance of peace and settlement of issues bilaterally as between India and Pakistan.

Today is St. Joseph's Day
Saint Joseph- patron of work

By P K Joseph Dhar

The entire catholic world comprising about 1.25 billion heads celebrate the feast of St. Joseph on March 19 each year. He was the person to whom an angel of the Lord appeared in a dream who had resolved to divorce Mary as she was found with a child before they had come together, saying; ''Joseph, son of David, do not fear to take Mary your wife, for that which is conceived in her is of the Holy spirit. She will bear a son and you shall call his name Jesus, for he will save his people from their sins''. (Mathew 1:20-21)

It is a common belief that he was a carpenter. But the Greek word the Gospel uses is ''technee'' which may mean one possessing more technical skill than suggested by carpenter. He had the technical skill to pursue to trade that included carpentary, welding, building of houses and boats that involved other professional skills. However, from this we cannot conclude he was just a labourer. That is one aspect of the work St. Joseph undertook. He is more fittingly called the worker. Worker would mean that he undertook not only carpentary to earn a living but invested his life in doing 'Opus Dei' or the work of God.

What was the 'Opus Dei' he performed? The answer is simple. He taught Jesus Christ to read and write, to study the scriptures and to worship. He also povided a conducive atmosphere for the child to absorb the Jewish culture and ethos. It is also apparent that he taught Jesus Christ certain skills appropriate to a growing child.

Saint Joseph took his profession very seriously as his God given vocation. It was not merely to earn a living that he persued it but to render service to God. He was doing excellent service when he raised Jesus Christ, the son of God to be a complete human being. All unawareness Saint Joseph was playing the part of God the father when he taught Jesus Christ carpentary and other skills that were at the same time imbued with the divine spirit. In this regard we can say that committed loving service was the purpose of all the work he undertook. This is all the more true when his service is contextualized, for he was serving Jesus Christ, God made man, even if he were not fully aware of it.

Saint Joseph was a model teacher and a model worker. Not only this, he was an exemplary parent and head of the first family of the world. He dedication to work was a clarion call to all workers ''workers of the world unite to serve with love! You have nothing to lose except your slavey to sin and utopian delusion.''

It shall not be impertinent at this point to probe a little deeper into the nature of work. If for a greater part of His life on earth Jesus Christ was a worker engaged in hard labour alongwith His foster, parent Saint Joseph. He certainly intended to reveal an aspect of human life of utmost importance viz value of Human Labour.

We all know that God has infused in every individual a very powerful urge to work and produce something. This creativity urge prompts one to explore, prove, invent, alter, construct, to progress and to experience the joy of doing. Here we can say that man needs to work because he is created in the image of God and always works.

Our Lord Jesus Christ came to build the bridge between God's work and man's. Lord God in Christ Jesus wanted to experience human work, and He experienced it under the tutelage of Saint Joseph. As a result, Lord Jesus Christ as man and God looks at work, with much love.

Every thinking mind shall not fail to understand the stark truth that our father in Heaven does not cease working even for a fraction of a moment. If He were so the entire scheme of things shall come to griding balt. This is also made clear by Jesus Christ Himself when he said, 'My father is still working and I also am working''. (John 5: 17). He said this to his opponents who were questioning His right to work on a Sabbath Day. Jesus Christ therefore, made it clear to them, that the greatest worker in the world is God Himself who works round the clock without ceasing. This gives us an idea of work both in the cosmic and earthly dimension. God's work has a definite link, with human existence. Thus work is woven into the very texture of human existence.

If we turn to the Book of Genesis of the Holy Bible the sacred writer says that on the first six days of the earth's existence God worked and He rested on the seventh. From this account, we can safely infer that the importance of work in the life of man is immensely highlighted.

We know from the life of our Lord Jesus Christ that in His native village Nazareth people took it for granted that He was a worker alongwith His foster parent Joseph in whose trade he was an apprentice at first: ''Is not this the carpenter the son of Mary''? (Mark 6:3). It is, therefore, Jesus Christ, the worker that inspires and shows the value of work in the right perspective. He is the one who animates families from the nuclear to the global, to live a more human life through work done with the awareness of its value. Our Lord Jesus Christ would not have wasted most of His lifetime on earth to work as a carpenter if it did not have salvific value.

In a spiritual sense Jesus Christ considers every worker in the world as Co-worker with Him for saving the world. Foremost among them is Joseph whose work was sanctified by Jesus Christ even before He was conceived in Mary's womb. Saint Joseph had the further privilege of introduction Lord Jesus Christ to human work that a time came when the carpenter of Nazareth would indicate either Saint Joseph or our Lord Jesus Christ interchangeably.

My obeisance to my patron Saint who infused in my soul the spirit of committed and dedicated work.

Perspective on saving environment

By Dr Navin Chandra Joshi

The annual review of environment 2000, brought out by the world bank, states that more than 20 per cent of the total burden of the explosive rise of various diseases in the Asian region is due to environmental factors. Over half of these are just from the polluted water and lack of sanitation, apart from the atmospheric pollution. More interesting is the publication. ''The state of the Food Insecurity in the World 2000'' a report of the Food and Agricultural Organisation (FAO) as it reveals that the State of undernourished and poor in South Asia is even worse than Africa, since more than 50 per cent children under the age of five are underweight as compared to 33 per cent in Africa. Yet, the two main countries of the region viz. India and Pakistan, alone are spending more than 12 billion dollars a year on military.

So then, no wonder there is a strong complementary between the goals of economic development and improvement in environment. ''The world has reached a common global understanding of fundamental threats to the earth's ecological balance,'' said Prime Minister, Atal Behari Vajpayee recently. He has called for making the global environment facility of the United Nations as a catalyst for universal participation and innovative programme for increasing awareness and a sense of urgency to develop and pursue a sustainable development path for the benefit of current and future generations.

Vajpayee is of the view that the rich countries should face problems by laying down stringent emission norms, including limits on pollutants and by enforcing these stringent norms and limits, but the developing world should also tackle the same by putting into place an incentive structure that encourage conservation and discourage the scavanging of nature, without compromising economic development and rapid alleviation of poverty.

The Earth consists of different components which are inseparable and integral to it. The gaseous atmosphere which envelops the Earth, the hydrosphere which contains all the water bodies, and the lithosphere, the solid uppermost layer of the Earth, are the important components for sustenance of life on the Earth. Pollution and destruction of any one of these 'spheres' affects the others since they are all interrelated. Thus, preservation of the environment needs an integral and holistic approach.

The quality of physical environment has been deteriorating continuously for the last many years. The quality becomes all the more disgusting because of the rapid growth of population and the subsequent fall in living standards in developing countries, including India.

And yet, the paradox is that the number of automobiles in urban areas- their ever-increasing number has become the most serious threat while aggravating air pollution through emissions of carbondioxide, nitrous oxide and suspened particulate matter (SPM) which today in all the metropolitan cities of India are much above the accepted norms in the embient air.

Non wonder, the increasing levels of air pollution pose dangerous implications for the health an work efficiency of the citizens.

The other important consumption item for human beings is water. Rivers and other water bodies which are the major sources of drinking water, are getting increasingly polluted by industrial and urban sewage disposals, along with negligent attitudes of the people. Even in the river Ganges, enonmous quantities of untreated domestic swage is poured into it along with effluents from a number of industries. From the point of its entry into Delhi till Chambal river joins it, the Yamuna is considered a dead river because of the release of around 2000 million litres of untreated sewage daily along its 22 km stretch in Delhi. So is the fate of most of the rivers that flow through big cities, especially in all countries of the developing world.

Obviously, therefore, the need of the hour is to save our natural habitat and heritage from getting polluted.

Sustainable development needs to become the new buzz word in environment circles. But how many of us understand its real meaning? for environmentalists, sustainable development denotes a radical change in our way of living, beginning with smaller populations. As such, family planners, not farmers or scientists, hold the key to future food supplies, global environment crisis has been contributed by both the grinding and pervasive poverty in the developing nations (called 'pollution of poverty') as well as of the humanity growing under sub-human conditions. Poverty itself has now become the 'biggest polluter'. The anatomy of the gathering environmental crisis is engulfed by this stark reality.

Therefore, the need of the hour is to cry halt to the process of senseless environmental destruction, lest the environmental crisis itself should overwhelm us. Being a multi-dimensional phenomenon, the environmental crisis must be dealt with as such, the only effective remedy for halting the growing hodes of environmental refugees is 'sustainable development accompanied by environmental conservation. New environmental ethos must pervade at all levels of our decision-making as well as allocation of funds for developmental goals.

It is true that environment, whether one likes it or not affects us all. And yet, most of us know very little about the major changes affecting the environment, dramatic shifts in the world's weather patterns or the detrimental effects of urban pollution. It is difficult to say precisely which is causing more havoc on environment reckless industrialisation or deforestation. In a way , both act in collusion.

The of the environment policy in developing countries has been on controlling pollution of any type, rather than preventing it. and yet, the 'polluter pays' principle has been found to be difficult to implement as there are clusters of small industries which do not have the access to, or the capital for technical knowhow for pollution control. The initiative has, therefore, to come from the government.

In a way, much of the development in the world today is not sustainable. It is based upon the squandering of our 'biological' capital viz, soil, forests animals, plant species and air. Many of our economic, monetary and trade policies in sectors such as energy, agriculture, forestry and human development tend to induce and reinforce non-sustainable development patterns and practices. As some patterns of development have improved environmental conditions, others have only tended them sometimes irreversibly.

In the last two decades or so, most of the developing countries have witnessed a steady increase in environmental degradation and many new industrialising countries have experienced massive environmental deterioration in the wake of sudden industrialisation and explosive urbanisation. The capacity of a number of developing countries to manage their environment, so as to secure the well-being of their people, is also coming under severe stress, following the rapid population growth, its uneven distribution and inadequate socio-economic development.

In fact, human survival depends upon the life activities of thousands of species of plants, animals and micro-organisms and upon intricate physical and chemical reactions in the atmosphere, oceans, fresh water and so on.

The vastness and complexity of this interdependence have already become evident with increasing human intervention into the life-giving processes of our planet. All life is dependent on the interaction of matter and energy carried out in the earth's ecosystem. It is these interactions which we are altering even before we fully comprehend them. The peope of the world must come to understand them to preserve them and when altering them, to tackle it with care and wisdom.

There is a fundamental conflict between traditional concepts of economic growth and the preservation of environment. During the last century, uncontrolled growth in industrial production of environmentally harmful substances and products in some regions of the world has produced dangerous amounts of pollution and has been responsible for an inordinate waste of resources. At the same time, an increasing concentration of industrial activity has led to centralisation, within a few nations, of the benefits of the earth's natural resources, and the international political influence that is derived from the control of the resources.

It has become clear that a more rational distribution of industrial power is necessary if the global problems of environment and society are to be solved. Such a distribution would achieve, at the same time, a more equal appropriation of economic and political benefits among nations and individuals.

In sum, the problem is quite complex and there is no single solution. In any case, it is high time that environmental tribunals are set up in our country to implement the environmental safeguards. Surely, any viable strategy must take into account not only the physical nature of the problem but also the human factor involved. Moreover, mere legislation can neve be a solution unless it is enforced strictly. If our environment is to be saved from further degradation, there is an urgent need to remove the lacunae in the implementation of environment protection laws. Otherwise, the vast majority will continue to pay the price for the misdeeds of a recalcitrant few.

PTI Feature

Dealing with Afghanistan

Neither the United Nations nor the sanctimonious West has covered itself with glory by showcasing their pusillanimous inaction in the face of the Taliban's criminal operations which are aimed at destroying not just statues, but an invaluable part of the world's cultural heritage going back to thousands of years. Religious fundamentalism almost always militates against the development of the finer aspects of human civilisation, though religions - Buddhism, Christianity, Hinduism, Islam - have contributed to the enrichment of philosophy, art, literature, and, crucially, human sensibility.

Even Marx acknowledged this when he wrote that religion was the heart of a heartless world and the sigh of the oppressed, even though it was the opium of the masses. Fundamentalism has always sought to deny the legitimacy of the corporeal form, by valorising the sphere of the sacerdotal and the spiritual. By doing so, it rejects the joyous celebration of the physical and material world, which is central to human existence. If religion were not to work towards the material rehabilitation of humanity it would be dead on arrival. In India, the saints who led the reformist Bhakti movement made a humanist statement which traditional, caste-bound Hindu society had to come to terms with. Much later, in Latin America "Liberation Theology" propagated by priests of the Catholic Church espoused the cause of the individuality and the right to dignified existence of the exploited peasants of that continent. That is the essence of religion - empathy in the search of a more equitable world.

It is intolerable that religion should be invoked to engage in the kind of vandalism that the Taliban have embarked upon. Destruction of statues goes hand in hand with arbitrary social sanctions - injunctions that deny women their fundamental and natural human rights, for instance. Talibanic Afghanistan is a travesty of humanity. Unfortunately, it has grown to be a Frankenstein monster which its sponsors cannot control anymore.

The Taliban have brushed aside Pakistan's appeal to spare the priceless monuments it has destroyed. The rest of the Islamic world has either ignored this act of barbarism or failed to dent the Taliban's resolve.

Given the fact that the Western world, especially the United States, has played a not inconsiderable role in the rise of the Taliban, the world has the right to expect that today's sole superpower will take immediate and sanguinary steps to subdue the Taliban's latest initiative. The US has shown great resolve in its attempts to have Osama bin Laden extradited. The United Nations has imposed sanctions against Afghanistan for sheltering him. But in a case where narrow national interest is not involved, the West has shamefully disengaged itself from what is undeniably a civilisational responsibility.

Signs of cold war rekindling in some form or the other are emanating from Washington. The Russian opposition to the new US missile defence systems is irritating the Americans. Pakistan can once again become a strategic partner for the US if it can assist in the hand-over of Osama bin Laden, and at the same time, destabilise Russia with the help of Taliban militia.

China surely is not amused at the possibility of 'Talibanised' unrest, if not awakening, in its own backyard bordering Afghanistan. But Beijing will not be averse to allowing the Taliban to stew in its own political juice of Islamic extremism inside Afghanistan, at least for some time, if there can be a strategic insurance against its export to China. Pakistan, as a conspicuous ally of the Taliban, can be expected to offer China such an assurance behind the scenes.

From the present standpoint of Pakistan, headed by an essentially 'secular' military ruler in Gen. Pervez Musharraf, the Taliban's fundamentalist energies can be stirred in ways detrimental to India in Jammu and Kashmir, which is very much seen by him to reflect the 'unfinished agenda of the partition' of the Indian subcontinent. This phrase was first used long before Gen. Musharraf emerged on the Pakistan scene as a secularist influenced by Kemal Ataturk of Turkey.

Now, the Taliban's strategic-tactical utility to Pakistan was the key factor that prompted Gen. Musharraf to blame India for a recent bomb explosion at a vegetable market on the outskirts of Islamabad, despite reports that the device was found in a crate of fruits coming from Afghanistan. India and the Taliban, which controls the area in question, have always been poles apart.

Uzbekistan, among all the Central Asian republics with erstwhile Soviet connections, reckons that the Taliban deserves to be kept at arm's length. On a separate plane, Teheran's equation with Washington has not stabilised since the Shia-slanted Iranian political revolution. Yet, Iran and the U.S., the latter after some cool calculations, share at this moment a strategic interest in stemming the tide of the Taliban inside and outside Afghanistan.

Russia, successor to the Soviet Union which beat a military retreat from Afghanistan under Mr. Mikhail Gorbachev's glasnost and perestroika as extended to foreign policy, is now under a President, Mr. Vladimir Putin, who cannot afford to leave Afghanistan to its own devices - such as those that the Taliban might provide as the predominant warlord in a failed state. The remnants of the Taliban's opponents are still being commanded by Mr. Ahmad Shah Masood, the renowned anti-Soviet guerrilla and a latter-day India-friendly leader.

Now, although not directly threatened by either a present or a potential Taliban wave, except in Chechnya, Moscow will nonetheless find itself constrained in its interactions with its former provinces of Central Asia, should these states face a Taliban-inspired insurgency within their own domains. Nor surprisingly, Mr. Putin is at present inclined to open a dialogue with Gen. Musharraf.

The latest India-U.S. unison over their current 'concerns' regarding Afghanistan is a far cry from the time immediately before and after the rise of the Taliban as a political force in 1994-95. Then, suspicions were up in the air that the U.S. might have masterminded a Taliban-style alternative to the interminably squabbling Afghan 'mujahideen' groups which had earlier been aided by the U.S., with Pakistan playing a Man Friday, in the war against the Soviet 'stooges' in Kabul. The U.S. has consistently refuted all suggestions that it was the brain behind the rise of the Taliban as an Afghan outfit with direct genetical roots in Pakistan's Islamis religious schools in the Quetta and Peshawar belts. Washington, it was said in the mid-1990s, would not wish to create a Frankenstein's monster in Afghanistan.

Yet, a fashionable theory right across the diplomatic spectrum in Islamabad during 1994-97, the period of the Taliban's ascendancy, was that Pakistan's intelligence output, Saudi Arabia's funds and the U.S.'s strategic resourcefulness were behind the initial momentum of that Sunni-Muslim fundamentalist outfit. The common interest of these countries was the establishment of some post-Soviet stability in Afghanistan in a reversal of its then rampant civil war phase which, to Islamabad's chagrin, was dominated by an India-friendly Mr. Masood.

Pakistan was at that time keen on the emergence of a friendly regime in Kabul, given that Islamabad would always regard Afghanistan as a realm of 'strategic depth' with reference to India. For Saudi Arabia, the bastion of the Sunni faith, an amenable Taliban would have been a useful counterpoise in Afghanistan in relation to its neighbouring Shia citadel of Iran - Riyadh's traditional rival in Islamic politics.

The U.S., on the other hand, was at that time reckoned to be in search of a stabilising force in Afghanistan, irrespective of its internal dynamics, so that drug trafficking and other newly-identified international scourges of a post-Cold War orientation could be controlled. The Taliban, with its initial puritanical opposition to the narcotics menace as amplified by Mullah Omar as its leader, was seen to suit the U.S. agenda of the mid-1990s in that pocket of the world. But, not so after the arrival of a Saudi dissident - Osama bin Laden who later acquired notoriety as a terrorist on Washington's list of wanted criminals - in the Taliban-controlled Afghan territory in 1996. This could have easily turned both the U.S. and Saudi Arabia against the Taliban, if these two countries had not blessed its rise in the first place.

If the Taliban had indeed chosen in 1996 to defy its alleged benefactors, the U.S. and Saudi Arabia, that could be traced to the rugged sense of fierce independence which the Afghans were known to cherish. It was against that balance-sheet that the Taliban's demonstrated 'restraint' at the Kandahar airport, at the height of the Indian Airlines' plane hijack drama there in December 1999, has not earned it any international acclaim as a responsible player, contrary to the view in Pakistan by observers of the Taliban phenomenon such as Kamal Matinuddin.

At another strategic level, despite Pakistan's constant efforts to woo the Afghans in its battle of wits with India, the leaders in Kabul have traditionally sought to play the so-called India card in order not to become subservient to Islamabad. That, in part, accounted for the move in the mid-1990s by Afghan Islamist leaders such as Prof. Burhanuddin Rabbani and Mr. Masood to try and build bridges with India. Given this historical reality, India may continue to figure in the strategic calculations of the future leaders in Kabul, if Afghanistan can be put back on its feet as a state within recognised boundaries. India needs to be associated with the U.N. caucus on Afghanistan, at least as an associate member, even if the caucus does not turn into an international conference on a failed but not forgotten state. INAV

 
 



|
home | state | national | business | editorial | advertisement | sports |
|
international | weather | mailbag | suggestions | search |
subscribe | send mail |