Government has
to downsized
Sir,
The fifth pay
commission carried the promise of downsizing the
government by 30 percent. That has not happened
so far. It appears that there is a deep rooted
bounding between the bureaucracy and the
political management leaving no scope for
political reform. This is quite unfortunate.
The Orrisa Super
Cyclone and now the Gujarat earthquake have
proved that the present system of administration
is important to meet challenge of any texture.
The whole thing is a gigantic mess of which the
upper echelon is a net work of non performing,
parasitic elite whose main function is not work
but supervision. If the calculation published in
a particular English weekly could be any guide we
spend Rs. 75,000/- crores a year in calories and
allied benefits on this mammoth structure
comprising the centre and the states. A Secretary
costs us Rs. 8 lakhs a month and an additional
Secretary Rs. 6.5. lakhs.
It shall not be
inappropriate to reproduce the observations of
Sam Pitroda, the noted technocrat reacting to our
management efforts in Gujarat. "I was
disappointed when I saw on the TV that in Gujarat
they have appointed a disaster Management
Committee with five Secretaries. You cannot do
that. You really need people from the Army and
the corporate sector who are more disciplined who
have a little more sense of urgency. You cannot
give disaster management to IAS officers. It does
not work like that. Our former Finance Minister
Mr. P. Chidambaram has not minced words in his
observation. We have one of the weakest executive
Governments in the world. The permanent civil
service is a huge burden on the exchequer and
provides little value for the money spent on it.
All this must go a drastic change. Even Jawahar
Lal Nehru did not fail to observe in an interview
shortly before his death. My inability to reform
the civil servants was one of my greatest
regrets.
What we need in
India, today, therefore, is that the government
has to be downsized, procedures simplified,
accountability introduced and enforced and those
incapable of changing themselves asked to go on
voluntary retirement. If this is not done then
the alarm posed by the incapable and lethargic
bureaucracy shall be heard with a funeral note
and the slab of this machinery which is not the
chests of the tax payers shall grind heavier
rendering us all immobile and ineffective.
Yours etc..
P K Joseph Dhar
Roop Nagar, Jammu.
|