EDITORIAL

Don't reward terrorism!

The blood bath in New York ensured that the world understood the reality of terrorism. Today, the world opinion is resolved that terrorism is not a justifiable whatever the provocation, whatever the cause, whatever the grievance. Indeed, who so ever indulges in terrorism actually betrays the cause he/she has been promoting. .. .more

Write letters, write

The other day we carried in our letters column a grateful letter-writer describing how his incessant airing of the problems of his locality had moved the authorities. Of course, all the letter writers are not so lucky. Especially with the authorities having given up their orientation towards the public for the loyalty towards the political bosses, there is a trend, so to say, of writing the public off. Those with powerful political connections do sometimes try to ignore the mass of people whom they are to serve. But that is not ... .more

Sitakant Mahapatra :
Scholar, bureaucrat
and poet

By Ashok K Choudhury
Why does one write ? Because sometimes one feels like saying something. This can very well apply to litterateur Dr Sitakant Mahapatra's own poems that span four fruitful decades. ''Poetry for me is the tale of this forty-year quest inadequate, incomplete never fully satisfying, ever generating new dimensions of experience and the words to clothe them. Every beginning is the realisation of new failure, and the search for an answer to those new questions- who am I and why I am here- ever conscious that of what I see, of what ........
more

Will cheaper money
revive economy?

By Umashankar Phadnis
A serious bid is being made by the Union Finance Minister and the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) to revive activity in different segment of the economy with a significant all round lowering of......
more

EDITORIAL

Don't reward terrorism!

The blood bath in New York ensured that the world understood the reality of terrorism. Today, the world opinion is resolved that terrorism is not a justifiable whatever the provocation, whatever the cause, whatever the grievance. Indeed, who so ever indulges in terrorism actually betrays the cause he/she has been promoting. Nobody who is a perpetrator of terror can be a seeker after freedom, equality or justice. Logically the systems of terror would result in greater terror, more perversities all around and impose a total lack of tolerance, which alone can be a basis for freedom liberty and justice. Plato's scheme of philosopher kings underscores the realization that justice can be possible only in a system that was rooted in a justice. Justice and fellowship cannot follow from a total devotion to blood and mayhem. Freedom cannot sprout from means that are negation of all freedoms or ideologies that do not recognize the right of man to be free and outspoken. The importance of 'ways and mean's in the evolution of a just system, which Gandhiji was so insistent upon, comes through in bold relief in the Taliban terrorist backdrop.

As we now realize the Taliban held millions of Afghans in total subjugation for half a decade. With a handful of terrorists on rampage the vast multitude of Afghans just could not refuse or rebel. There may have been some sympathy for them and their ways but there was little support in the Afghan society for the stark terror the regime unleashed upon them. Yet not a murmur was heard, not even a sigh was allowed. Was that a reason why the lakhs of Afghans living as refugees in Pakistan refused to return to their homes while the Taliban ruled? But Taliban is not the only instance of the ultimate betrayal in the scheme of terror. That first revolution of modern world, the French revolution began as a terror-filled backlash by the people. While it lasted even with the freedom-loving philosophers in the saddle, the terror remained unabashed. It was only with the ascendancy of Napoleon that order was restored. The Bolsheviks overwhelmed all opposition-they were the minority opinion in then Russia, remember-with stark terror and killings. No sooner did Lenin die, that the whole soviet state was transformed into a total terror machine. It brought no freedom, no openness and finally cracked.

The newest of terrorism has fortunately now cracked up into waters. The world did finally see to it that the premise of terror was shattered good. Today terrorism is a reviled thing it should always have been. Probably, people would keep getting angry, the world would be getting unequal and unjust now and then, here and there, again. It shouldn't, but perhaps that is the nature of man; he tends after all refinements to get crude and barbaric. There would be need to wage struggles. But let not the world again pass into a celebration of terror. Terrorism should just not be acceptable or available as a means of attaining redressal and reprieves. The people around the world must realize that association with terrorism would not further their causes nor bring redressal of even genuine grievances. Indeed, a link with terrorism should be a disability. And the people associated with terror may in rare cases be forgiven but may not be forgotten for the crimes they committed. And those many more they would have committed had their reign not been cut short. Yes, terrorism should not be rewarded in any manner, if we want to rid the world of its menace.

Write letters, write

The other day we carried in our letters column a grateful letter-writer describing how his incessant airing of the problems of his locality had moved the authorities. Of course, all the letter writers are not so lucky. Especially with the authorities having given up their orientation towards the public for the loyalty towards the political bosses, there is a trend, so to say, of writing the public off. Those with powerful political connections do sometimes try to ignore the mass of people whom they are to serve. But that is not the rule. The authorities can ignore the public only at their own peril. The political bosses have ultimately to go the people. And, then, there are genuinely caring men and women in the Government-a dwindling number no doubt but they are there-who take the people seriously enough. And vox populi has that divine ring around it, which compels all to listen in the end. But for that to take effect the people have to speak. They have to air their problems and push their grievances to the fore. They have to highlight the omissions and bring the wrong-commissions to the notice of the fellowmen and the Government.

Somehow a despondency has taken root that the things would not improve. The people assume that nobody would listen and stop speaking. Most of the times this dismay is simply assumed not a tried and tested one. There may an air of dismissal around, a hautre in the administrative and governmental circles that they need not pay heed to the general public. That however should be a reason for the people to speak even more loudly, even more insistently. In fact the election vote is a reflection of the peoples decision at one point of time. The popularity then goes on to increase or decrease as the elected authority goes about its job. A good barometer of the popularity is the satisfaction or dissatisfaction of the people expressed through these columns. A silence here gets interpreted as an approval of the government, an acceptance of the activities and policies as good and beneficial. To register its dissatisfaction the people must bring their complaints to fore. Also, the Government that wants to the responsive and sensitive to the feelings and perceptions of the people has to be told what the popular perceptions are. And even the most irresponsive administrations cannot ignore the voice of the people; never for all the time. Only the people need to speak. Incessantly. Boldly. Profusely. The dynamics of democracy demands that.

Sitakant Mahapatra : Scholar, bureaucrat and poet

By Ashok K Choudhury

Why does one write ? Because sometimes one feels like saying something. This can very well apply to litterateur Dr Sitakant Mahapatra's own poems that span four fruitful decades. ''Poetry for me is the tale of this forty-year quest inadequate, incomplete never fully satisfying, ever generating new dimensions of experience and the words to clothe them. Every beginning is the realisation of new failure, and the search for an answer to those new questions- who am I and why I am here- ever conscious that of what I see, of what I experience, only a wee bit I seem to understand, and everyday the feeling grows that perhaps I understand less and less'', says Sitakant Mahapatra.

He is one of the foremost voices in the contemporary modern Indian poetry. Prof Heinrich van Stietencron, translator and editor of the poet's anthology in German, says, ''Among the significant poets of contemporary India, Sitakant Mahapatra deserves special attention. Known and recognised internationally, Dr Mahapatra is a poet who has stressed new emphases and projected new patterns between the limitations of western influences and classieesoteric tradition'.

For creativity, depth and uncompromising dedication in the field of literature, Dr Mahapatra was awarded 'Kabir Samman' for the year 2000-2001. The Award has been instituted by Madhya Pradesh government in the field of Indian poetry. Recently Dr Mahapatra has also been given an international award, 'Highest Honour' of Osaka University, Japan at a special convocation in April 2001.

Dr Mahapatra was the recipient of the 29th Bharatiya Jnanpith Award (1993) for his outstanding contribution to the enrichment of Indian literature during the period 1973-92. The Award citation states that 'the poetic vision of Dr Mahapatra is a blend of timelessness and social consciousness. It encompasses in itself a quest for the fine, sensitive, a dialectics of the 'I' and 'other' and an aesthetic presentation of mythological content and eternal truth. Though deeply steeped in Western literature, Sitakant's pen has the rapturous fragrance of the native soil. His insight into the rich simplicity of rural and tribal life-style acquired during his illustrious administrative career is reflected in all his creative works''.

Joshuna Foundation's 'Joshua Sahitya Puraskar' is the richest among Indian awards and is given to poets. This award is given to those whose works uphold values of humanism, secularism and national integration. Dr C Narayan Reddy, the then Chairman of the Selection Committee of Joshuna Award, said, ''Dr Mahapatra bagged the award because of his rich contribution to poetry.''

It is, however, difficult to introduce a major poet, who is still in his prime. Exactly for that reason, it is even more difficult to evaluate his poetry on terms of his contribution to literature. These difficulties get compounded when he writes primarily in a regional language like Oriya, represents a quest that is essentially Indian and shows in his craft a play of spirit that is contemporary and global. Yet, it is in these difficulties that Dr Mahapatra gives away the clue to the understanding of his poetry. ''A typical product of the conflict between the forces of rejection and affirmation, he offers a synthesis of dialectical conflict between reason and passion'' say Harprasad Das.

In the Meet the Author programme arranged by Sahitya Akademi on 18 December 1992, in which Dr Mahapatra, in the course of his talk, related the events in his lie and the growth of his literary career. His recalled the influences of Achyut, Yasovant and Bhim Bhoi and also his father, who initiated him into the grand epic tradition of Indian and Oriya poetry mirrored in books such as the Mahabharata and the Bhagavata and Oriya classical poetry. He wrote his first poem'' Asur O'Swad'' (Relish of Tears) in 1973 and it became the opening poem in his first anthology Dipti O Dyuti.

When Dr Mahapatra published Dipti O Dyuti (The Glow and the Illumination), his first anthology containing forty-seven poems, in 1963, discerning critics immediately noticed a new voice. In spite of their simple structure, the poems show a high degree of sophistication and richnes. This volume contained almost all the themes which were to bloom into fullness in his later works. It contains some well-known poems like, 'Jara Sabarara Sangita,' 'Basra Darpanare Suryasta', Saharare Grishmas, Saharara Itikatha, etc very much in the tradition of Oriya poetry with its intricate mix of metaphysical pessimism and lyrical intensity and at the same time profoundly down to earth and using a language that had the distinct flavour of the soil. In Dipti O Dyuti, as a whole, those aspects may be noted a picture of familiar realistic life which fill in the details of the structural references to mythological situations on consciousness which provide a perspective in the poems; and finally as the creative imagination coordinates these two aspects it evolves a desire to get strength or to come to an understanding of the vital sources of life.

Astapadi (Eight steps, 1967), Mahapatra's second anthology, a collection of eight long poems which draws heavily on Indian and world mythology in respect of their imagery and insights-Kubuja come from Mathuramangala, Devaki from Bhagavata, and Solan from the nowhere island. Here the poet showed the structure of his mythical imagination. The use of myth as an integral part of the total poetic structure is seen to its best advantage in Astapadi Dr Mahapatra forays into the protagonist's inner universe which is torn apart by anguish, reveals the diverse layers of his existential confrontation and then affirms his faith in a hopeful future. His tender approach towards the protagonist develops into exchanges between the reality's many faces and the self's various manifestations.

Similar efforts had been made before, in modern Oriya poetry, by Guruprasad Mohanty in his Samudrasnana, consisting of Kalapurusha and other poems. Several passages in Astapadi bear close resemblance, both the magic and rhythmic, to passages in Guruprasad poems. Several passages in Astapadi bear close resemblance, both the magic and rhythmic, to passages in Guruprasad poems. The model is obviously TS Eliot. However, the book is the first elaborate statement of Dr Mahapatra's themes; Time, Death, Redemption. Astapadi was hailed as giving a new direction to Oriya poetry for its profound use of archetype, images and symbols, which won him the Oriya State Sahitya Akademi Award in 1971.

Dr Mahapatra won India's National Academy Award, at the age of 37, in 1974 for his third anthology, Shabdara Akash (The Sky of Words, 1971). A Collection of thirty-five poems, it is considered an outstanding contribution to Oriya poetry for its mythical framework and powerful language. In these poems, metaphor continues his earlier important trend of integrating myth or the universality of meaning which a myth provides, with the understanding of life's complexity, richness and profundity in a way rarely matched in Oriya poetry today. The title of the book is indicative of the poet's continuing concern with words. It explores these themes with vigour. The poems are relatively free from the verbosity of Astapad and are formally better executed. The Award made a mention of the competent use of myth in a modern context and the immense flavour of folk idioms.

With Astapadi and Shabdara Akash, Dr Mahapatra showed his innovative mode of handling myth and irony. And the poem began to unravel a journey within the self, that is confronted with existential problems as well as with the problems of creation. He revitalised his quest for an idiom that could meaningful minimise the gap between experience and expression. And his quest for silence is the manifestation of his pursuit of perfection and truth in poetry.

In Samudra (The Sea, 1977), an anthology of forty-four poems, where the sea provides the main motive force, are together in the form of an extended metaphor. These poems deal with isolation, suffering and agony, where the traditional sources of life fall and where the sea symbolises destruction the instrument of final deluge. Differently, the sea is also seen as the primary source of life, the repository of all knowledge and generates a cycle of fertility and fruitfulness. It is a whole new theory of human destiny, new in the sense that it breaks through the classical romantic facade of fatalism and weaves a brand new tapestry of durable material for daily use.

The next anthology Chitranadi (The Painted River, 1979) continues the intensity and sharpness of Samudra, the hope of man's redemption is more pronounced. But the archetypal Universality of the sea has been replaced by a contemplation of life in general. However, in Samudra and Chitranadi, Dr Mahapatra made his narrative symbolic, and hence his poetry became more inward looking, compendious, and of linguistic precision. His poetry became a happy blend of tradition, continuity and change. Rooted in the earth, his poetic vision expands beyond the horizon to identify the innermost mysteries existing between the human world and the natural world-the one reciprocates in making the other meaningful.

Dr Mahapatra returns to his old hunting ground of mythical constructs, but as a changed person in Aaradrushya (The other view, 1981). The title poem refers to the vision seen by Yasoda in Krishna's mouth, as a vehicle for conveying the idea that love for the earth carries with it the penalty of burying the great vision of life in death. Aaradrushva won Sitakant the Sarala Award in 1985.

His tenth anthology published in 1991 entitled Pheri Asibara Bela (The Time of Return) was followed by Shreshtha Kavita (Selected Poems), a comprehensive selection from all the ten anthologies, published in 1992. Varsha Sakal (A Rainy Morning, 1993) is considered a unique phenomenon, not because of the novelty of the utterance, but of the continuity of the quest. It is the journey, not of a poet merely, but of an entire aesthetic mode of search of the final repose of art, if that would ever be found. Dr Mahapatraha till now published thirteen anthologies, the latest being Kapatapasa (The Deceitful Game of Dice), a collection of fifty-three poems. He owes the first poem to the great blind Kondh poet of Orissa, Bhima Bhoi.

Dr Mahapatra's poetic journey began with the innocence of rusticity and childhood. In his recent poems one realises a new beginning, a new dawn heralded by the indisputable flux of time. The numerous themes on which he writes are enriched by intensity and authenticity of experience. He had his initiation into poetry writing through an inspiration he had got from English and American poetry with his associated trends and turning points. It is perhaps that inspiration which has made his what he is, a maker of poetry. He has tried his best to express in Oriya what he has gathered from remote pastures and garden.

Well-versed in the traditions of modern poetry in the west, Dr Mahapatra had equally deep perception of the Oriya poetic tradition. He has a rich and varied experience of life and poetry. Sarala Das, the first important name is Oriya literatuer and writer of Oriya Mahabharata; Jagannath Das, the poet of Oriya Bhagabata, have been the most profound influence on him, according to his own statement. The cultural and physical landscape of his state came out clear in his poetry and the give it a quality of intensity with their life rhythms.

Dr Mahapatra bridges two major gaps in the chronology of poetic utterance. He links Oriya poetry with the grand tradition and, having done that he lays anchor in the safety of his contemporary haven, and in the process brings the contemporary close to the modern. The metaphysical lyrics of the latest phase of his work symbolise his bridging of distances that existed so long. In making his poetic utterances, as the Swedish commentator Olls Malmagren says, ''a confluence of the Sanskrit religious-mythical tradition, the European lyrical modernism and the folk poetry of his home province Orissa's sun-drenched villages', Dr Mahapatra gives an entirely new ethos and meaning to modern Indian poetry, and a poetic culture that mixes sublimity and concreteness in equal measure.''

Dr Mahapatra is one of the few Indian poets to be translated into most European languages like English, German, Swedish, Danish, Romanian, Spanish, Macedonian and in one non-European language, Hebrew. In English translation, there are nine anthologies. The translations have been noticed for their rich imagery, the powerful use of folk idiom and a vivid, rugged language that stands for its vitality even under the inevitable limitation of translation. The translations speak of the recognition that his poems have received in the European world.

His poems have also been translated into all major Indian languages: Hindi (ten), Bengali (four), Urdu (two), Malayalam (four), Punjabi (three) and one each in Marathi, Maithili, and Dogri. As a good example of excellent translation of poetry from one language to another, the translation of Shabdar Akash into Dogri. (Akkhar Gaas, by Padma Sachdev) won him the prestigious Sahitya Akademi Translation Prize in 1999. The literary merit of the poem is effectively retained in the translation. Hence this work is considered an invaluable addition to Indian poetry in Dogri translation.

Besides being one of India's most important poets. Dr Mahapatra is also one of the country's celebrated social anthropologists with particular interest in the rich culture of its tribal population. Today he is looked upon as the foremost interpreter of the oral poetry of Indian tribes, of which he has translated and edited ten anthologies of the Mundas, the Oraons, the Santhals, the Kondhs and the Parajas. His translations of the oral verse of the tribes give us intimate visual and aural pictures of these people in many of his poems. Dr Mahapatra has also translated Srikant Verma's anthology of poems Magadh (1970), and Surya Trushana (1982), an anthology of modern Macedonian poetry into Oriya.

As an eminent anthropologist Utkal University awarded, Dr Mahapatra a Ph.D for his doctoral dessertation, Modernisation and Ritual: Search for Identity Among the Primitive Communities of India, which has since been published by Oxford University Press.

As an essayist, Dr Mahapatra has published four collections of essays in literature and culture in Oriya and several anthologies of such essays in English. These writings won him the Orissa Sahitya Akademi Award again in 1984. Aneka Sharat (Many Autumns, 1981) is a travelogue of Dr Mahapatra of his travels in East European countries during the last three decades. For Sahitya Akademi, Dr Mahapatra has written two monographs on Bhima Bhoi and Jagannath Das for its Makers of Indian Literature series. This series consists of monographs on outstanding Indian writers who have made a significant contribution to the development of literature in the Indian languages and are primarily intended for readers who have no direct access to the work of the writer concerned.

As a distinguished scholar and poet, Dr Mahapatra has delivered lectures at national and international seminars. He was invited to deliver the Keynote Address in the Lester Peason Centre for Development Studies in the University of Dalhousie, Canada, in 1985, chaired a session in the 10th World Congress of Anthropological and Ethnological Science in 1978; delivered the 10th Samvatsar Lecture, the annual lecture of Anthropological and Ethnological Science in 1978, delivered the 10th Samvatsar Lecture, the annual lecture of the Sahitya Akademi, which is given by a distinguished writer and creative thinker, who has a thorough understanding of Indian literature in 1995. Dr Mahapatra was born on 17th Sept. 1937 in Mahanga village of district Cuttack, Orissa. The village is perched on the bank of the river Chitropala, a branch of the turbulent Mahanadi. The river recurs as a persistent reality in the poetry of Dr Mahapatra. He had a brilliant academic career, always standing first. After matriculation from a local high school and graduating from Ravenshaw College, Cuttack, in 1957 in History Honours, he did his MA in political science from the University of Allahabad in 1959. He started his career as lecturer in Ravenshaw College and left teaching in 1961 to join the Indian Administrative Service, having topped the list of successful candidates. He has held several responsible positions both in the State and Central governments before retiring as Secretary, Culture Department.

He has been a fellow in the University of Cambridge (1868-69) as a Colombo Plan Fellow and in the University of Harvard as a Senior Fellow (1987-88). During 1975-77 he pursued his research work as a Homi Bhabha Fellow studying the modernisation process of the tribal societies in Eastern India. He is doing research now as a senior Fellow.

Dr Mahapatra was associated wih the Sahitya Akademi as a member of its executive board, and the Bharatiya Jnanpith as a member of its Central Selection Committee. He was President, UNESCO's World Decade for Cultural Development (1994-96), and Honorary Fellow, International Academy of Poets, Cambridge. Presently, he is Chairman, National Book Trust, India.

The long list of awards received by Dr Mahapatra should suffice to speak about his writing excellence. He combines in him a brilliant academician, a competent civil servant, and a poet of rare talent in providing powerful leadership to post-Independence new poetry movement in Oriya. His excellence lies in extending the horizon of modern Indian poetry by the powerful use of tradition, which blends with the complexity of the modern mind.- CNF

Will cheaper money revive economy?

By Umashankar Phadnis

A serious bid is being made by the Union Finance Minister and the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) to revive activity in different segment of the economy with a significant all round lowering of interest rates. It is expected that this move on the part of the Finance Minister and the monetary authorities will facilitate an increase in investment in projects in power, oil, transport and telecommunication sectors. It is, at the same time, hoped that the demand for various manufactured goods will get stimulated, especially as the exemplary behaviour of the agricultural sector should be resulting in an improvement in disposable incomes of the population in the semi-urban and rural areas.

The bank rate has, thus, been reduced to 6.5 per cent, the lowest level since 1973, from 7 per cent while the cash reserve ratio (CRR) has been slashed by two percentage points to 5.5 per cent in two stages resulting in an augmentation of the resources of the banking system to the extent of Rs. 8,000 crores. The scheduled commercial banks will also have the benefit of the exemption of several types of deposits from the purview of CRR.

However, there has not been any hurry on the part of many bankers to reduce further prime lending rates (PLRs) along with lending rates applicable to several categories of borrowers. The major banks are actually worried about an erosion of profitability, if there had to be a cut in lending rates, as credit off-take has been disappointing. In the process, it has become necessary to deploy surplus resources in Government securities.

The cheaper money policy, being pursued by the RBI, will not be conferring any special advantage when effecting exports in spite of a cheapening of export credit, as interest rates world wide have been on the downtrend. The Federal Reserve Board (FRB) of the U.S. particularly, has been slashing its discount rate and it is now as low as 2 per cent as compared to 6 per cent early this year. Several central banks with the European Union too have been reducing their interest rates.

The question, however, has been asked in industry circles whether lower interest rates, by themselves, will have a triggering effect on the economy in the absence of new measures for bringing about a smart recovery in stock markets. It is argued that there will have to be a big step up in investment in sectors, where there had been slack in progress due to the absence of any noticeable increase in investment on new and expansion projects.

The finances of the Central and State Government also are in poor shape and it will not be possible to achieve the target for Plan expenditure, as tax revenues may turn out to be considerably short of the budget estimates in all cases. With mounting non-plan expenditure and small rise in Plan outlays as well, the fiscal deficits of the Centre as well as the States are bound to be much larger than visualised.

The only comforting feature so far as the Centre is concerned is the facility to borrow in larger volume on a cheaper basis. The net amount secured through market loans up to November 9, 2001 was higher at Rs. 62,896 crores against Rs. 53,026 crores in the corresponding period in 2000. The Reserve Bank has not been obliged to take up new loans on its own account in the current year so far, as the loans privately placed with the RBI amounted to only Rs. 21,679 crores against Rs. 30,151 crores in the period under reference. Open market sales, on the other hand, accounted for Rs. 27,379 crores against Rs. 17,817 crores. There has, thus, been a net reduction in holdings of Reserve Bank in Central Government securities.

The Union Finance Ministry has also obtained its requirements advantageously, as the yields on all types of loans have been on the downtrend. This will be evident from the fact that the 10-year loan issued on April 11, 2000 had a cut-off yield of 10.26 per cent, while the same loan offered on September 18, 2001 had a cut-off yield of 9.41 per cent. Again, the 15-year loan issued on December 26, 2000 afforded an yield of 11.45 per cent, while it was much lower at 9.80 per cent, when it was issued on August 30, 2001. The quotations for different loans have understandably improved and banks have been enabled to secure higher other incomes.

While the privileged borrowers have been beneficiaries, the objective of reviving the economy cannot be achieved without a step up in investment in vital areas. The anticipated advantage out of a record agricultural production need not necessarily be responsible for a recovery in the industrial sector, as difficulties are being experienced in tackling plentiful supplies. In the absence of the much-needed growth in internal consumption of foodgrains, a higher level of production has been resulting only in bulging buffer stocks. These are excepted to be at the forbidding level of 75 million tonnes. The aggregate output of foodgrains in the current agricultural season is estimated at the all time high of 210.10 million tonnes against 196.10 million tonnes and 208.90 million tonnes in the two previous seasons. With a larger output of oilseeds and cotton and the maintenance of sugarcane production at high levels, open market prices for various commodities have tended to decline.

With lower crude oil prices in world markets too, the inflation rate has dipped to as low as 2.59 per cent in the week ended October 27 from 7 per cent in the corresponding week a year ago. With a record agricultural output and reduced inflationary pressures, there should have been an improvement in industrial production. But the industrial output has risen by only 2.3 per cent in April-September 2001 against 5.7 per cent in the same half year in the previous year and it will be a surprise, if the growth turns out to be around 4 per cent in the whole year as compared to 5.1 per cent.

All the major industries are finding it difficult to maintain production at the desired rate, as exports too have declined by 1.95 per cent in April-September 2001 against a growth of 20.4 per cent in the whole of 2000-01.

In the prevailing dismal situation, it is imperative that there should be an increase in outlays in vital sectors with an improvement in the investment climate and larger foreign direct investment. There are, of course, signs of recovery in the bourses. But even with recent gains, the Bombay Sensitive Index is nearly 50 per cent of the all time record of 6150.69 touched on February 14, 2000. The availability of bulging forex reserves, by themselves, cannot be a helpful factor, though the balance of payments position will remain comfortable with the drop in the oil import bill offsetting nearly the adverse effect of lower export earnings. With subsiding inflationary pressure, even an enlargement of the Centre’s fiscal deficit for productive purposes will not have a queering effect. The huge surpluses with banks can, thus, be meaningfully utilised for boosting investment by profitably functioning enterprises in the public and private sectors.

In the absence of an increase in credit off-take, banks have excess investments in Government securities of as much as Rs. 129,450 crores over the minimum statutory liquidity ratio (SLR) of 25 per cent. "The kick starting of the economy can, thus, be initially attempted with an optimum use of current inflows on capital account and the lendable resource of banks. The momentum gained thereby can be sustained, if the secondary and primary markets too can be revived and sizable savings of the community chanalised into the desired directions. INAV

A cloning storm rocks human world

By Anita Bhatt

Fresh furore has been caused over the claims of the United States' Advanced Cell Technology (ACT) researchers that they have successfully cloned the first human embryo. Most of the reactions were apprehensive of the consequences of this achievement. Fears of this leading up to full-fledged human cloning were promptly met with assurances that the ''work sets the stage for human therapeutic cloning as a potentially limitless source of immune-compatible cells for tissue engineering and transplantation medicine,'' as Dr Robert P Lanza, one of the researches of the Act said.

Top company executive Michael West also made it clear that they had no interest in transplanting such early embryos into a woman's womb to give birth to a cloned human being.

The joint declaration made some time back by Dr Severino Antonori, Director, International Associate Research Institute, Italy, Professor Michael Zaros, Andrology Institute, Kentucky, and Brigitte Boisselier, Director, Clonaids, Bahamas, to go for human cloning by the end of the year has again sparked a hot debate over the ethical and social dangers of this half-perfected technique. These scientists too faced large scale protest from all over the world. It weas then categorically declared that the IARI would respect the protocol of the Council of Europe forbidding the creation of a human being genetically identical to another.

In July, the House of Representatives approved a broad legislation that would define cloning both for producing children and using it as a medical tool a criminal act. If the measure had already become law, ACT chief executive Michael West and his colleagues could be subjected to jail terms to 10 years and $ one million in fines for the work they had published last Sunday.

The sensational announcement made by the Advanced Cell Technology (ACT), a privately owned US company, that it has successfully used cloning technology to grow a cluster of human stem cells has once again brought the old debate centrestage. ACT scientists say this step is a milestone in therapeutic cloning, and their aim is eventually to create cells that can be requisitioned to save any human organ that needs regeneration.

As ACT itself said, it does not wish to create cloned human beings, but to formulate life-saving therapies for a variety of diseases, including diabetes, cancer, AIDS, Parkinson's and Alzheimer's. Contrary to popular perception, medical science is still in its infancy when it comes to tackling the scourge of death and disease. The original Dr Frankenstein, British scientist Ian Wilmut, who created the first cloned adult mammal. Dolly, has said it is just a ''yard-stone'' and certainly not a ''milestone'' in medical research.

But the instant reaction to ACT's announcement was overwhelmingly negative. Religious groups and US political leaders slammed it as a ''moral breakdown''. From the religious-minded there were anguished cries about human reproduction having passed from the hands of God into the hands of mere mortals.

The White House last Sunday reiterated US President George W Bush's ''100 per cent opposition to human cloning in response'' to a medical breakthrough announced by the Massachusetts-based team of researchers. The President has ''made it clear 100 per cent that he is opposed to any type of human cloning''. White House spokesperson Jennifer Millerwise said.

What is cloning? Producing multiple, exact copies of a single gene, other DNA segments, an entire cell or a complete organism. Cloned collections of DNA are called clone libraries and are useful tools in helping scientists piece together our genetic information.

At the Roslin Institute, Edinburgh, under the supervision of Dr Wilmut, the scientist, who created the first clone of an adult animal- a lamb named 'Dolly'' produced from sheep, admitted on Feb 25, 1997 that the technique he used on the animal could be applied to humans. The same technique has been used to produce two more sheep, named Polly and Molly, who like Dolly, were grown from fertilised eggs which had their own nuclei replaced by nuclei taken from the body cell of other sheep.

Process : It is now possible, after a fertilized egg has first divided into two cells, to take one cell and use it to test for genetic diseases. The tested cell could have developed into a baby, if placed in a woman's womb.

Cloning is all about exact copying of the human gene to produce a child identical to its progeniter. Scientists are planning to opt for the 'Nuclear Transfer Cloning' process, in which a cell is taken from anywhere in the human body and its nucleus removed. Then the nucleus is replaced with the nucleus of an unfertilised egg. Finally, the egg is transferred into the uterus of a surrogate mother. There, like a normal foetus, the human clone develops in a process that lasts the usual nine months.

The fact is that by and large, scientists are unable to explain the high fertility rates of cloned animals. Examples are numerous. In December 1998 researchers at the Kinki University, Japan, cloned eight genetically identical cows from only ten implanted embryos. Four of them died within a few days of birth. Researchers at the Organ Regional Private Research Centre in Beaverten, USA, have tried hundreds of times to clone a single monkey. They have not succeeded yet. Even Dolly, the celebrated ewe, represents one success out of 277 embryos, nine of which were implanted and only Dolly survived.

Still, scientsts already have created animals fitted with human genes to produce proteins in their milk that can be used for treating diseases such as emphysema, cystic fibrosis and haemophilia.

Dr Harry Griffith, assistant director of the Roslin Institute, says that at present it is only possible to transfer gens to animals, but in the future, it may be a possible also to delete genes. And one of the most exciting things that is has created the first cloned pigs, offering hope of farming animals for organs such as hearts and kidneys to transplant into humans, provided the problem of rejection can be overcome. Transplanting a pig's organs has been attempted, but it must be genetically altered for acceptance by a human body, and countless tests must be done to ensure that dormant viruses would not be passed on to humans.

Clearly, if it is tough to clone animals, which it is at present, it would be more so in case of human cloning.

Should we clone Homo Sapiens?

The human mind, of course, is a dynamic entity, but genes are static. The point that brains, not gens, are the source of our uniqueness is further underscored by the fact that no one argues that natural clones, otherwise called identical twins, are the same person, even though they share an identical set of genes. They have different brains and experience the world from two different points of view.

The most common arguments for and against cloning, include the potential for abuse of the process, while the most urgent ethical, morally objectionable, legal and social issues about human cloning arise from the context and they process that may lead to the birth of first human clone. This is so because, as has been pointed out by scholars, early human experiments are likely to result in a number of clinical failures and lead to miscarriages and the necessity of dozens or even hundreds of abortions or birth of largely deformed offsprings. Thus, cloned human beings might have various health and genetics-related problems. The misuse of human cloning can promote eugenics and the manner in which it could infringe upon a person's sense of individuality.

Religious fundamentalist are also against cloning of animals. They take it as an ''interference in the God's work''.

On the positive side, human cloning proves medically beneficial to the seriously ill and these benefits outweight the moral and philosophical objections.

Although there is much elation at the rapid advances made in genetic engineering, understandably there is concern about the misuse of such immensely powerful biotechnology, which can result in unforeseen consequences for mankind. Trying to make a baby, rather a designer baby, someone else than the hereditary person it was meant to be, would be a tragedy.

Though human cloning is going to be a reality in the near future, we must keep certain questions under consideration: whether or not cloning of humans would be possible, should even an attempt in that direction be considered unethical? This kind of a development may pose a fundamental question: how far can man go in for biological engineering and against the laws of nature? And finally : is cloning necessary at all?- CNF-

 
 



|
home | state | national | business | editorial | advertisement | sports |
|
international | weather | mailbag | suggestions | search |
subscribe | send mail |